Skip to content

Establish Differential Testing Against an Autoware Reference #752

Open

Description

@ytakano

Build a reproducible comparison workflow between the Awkernel preprocessing-to-NDT pipeline and a fixed Autoware reference implementation using identical inputs and equivalent algorithm parameters.

Scope:

  • Pin the Autoware commit, relevant dependencies, build configuration, and parameter files
  • Prepare shared test datasets, point cloud maps, coordinate transforms, timestamps, and per-scan initial pose estimates
  • Compare intermediate outputs after crop box filtering and voxel grid downsampling
  • Compare final NDT poses, convergence outcomes, and iteration counts
  • Define numerical tolerances and comparison rules for point ordering, point fields, and floating-point differences
  • Generate machine-readable results and a summary of mismatches
  • Implement Point Cloud Replay and Validate the Preprocessing-to-NDT Pipeline

Acceptance criteria:

  • Both implementations process the same scans, maps, and initial pose estimates without independently evolving their inputs.
  • Parameter mappings and any unavoidable implementation differences are documented.
  • Intermediate point clouds are compared using an order-independent method where ordering is not part of the interface contract.
  • Position and orientation differences are evaluated against predefined tolerances.
  • Convergence-status differences and iteration-count differences are reported; exact iteration-count equality is required only where explicitly justified.
  • The comparison detects deliberately introduced output mismatches.
  • Test data identifiers, commands, configurations, and results are sufficient to reproduce each comparison.

Out of scope:

Performance benchmarking, scheduler evaluation, EKF integration, and proof of correctness against ground truth.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions