Skip to content

Agent Review: Auditable Review Intelligence for Document Workflows - #216

Open
Vishwak-8055 wants to merge 2 commits into
superdocsapp:mainfrom
Vishwak-8055:feat/agent-review
Open

Agent Review: Auditable Review Intelligence for Document Workflows#216
Vishwak-8055 wants to merge 2 commits into
superdocsapp:mainfrom
Vishwak-8055:feat/agent-review

Conversation

@Vishwak-8055

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Overview

Adds a self-contained Agent Review use case under
use-cases/Vishwak-8055/agent-review/.

The implementation treats document review as an evidence and state
problem rather than simply accepting AI-generated edits. It provides
structured change analysis, claim reconciliation, review state,
auditability, side-effect detection, persistence, and deterministic
revert capabilities.

What this adds

  • Evidence-aware document change modeling
  • Chunk-level change detection and comparison
  • Claim reconciliation across document states
  • Structured review state management
  • Auditable review history
  • Persistence and deterministic revert handling
  • Live side-effect detection
  • Session/change monitoring
  • Explicit document invariants and safety checks
  • SuperDocs client integration boundary
  • Review panel and webview presentation
  • Dedicated automated test coverage

Architecture

The implementation separates the core review concerns into focused
modules:

  • changeModel — represents and classifies document changes
  • chunkDiff — performs granular document comparison
  • claimReconciler — evaluates claim/evidence consistency
  • reviewStore — manages review state
  • auditLog — preserves review history
  • liveSideEffects — identifies downstream effects
  • persistence — handles durable state
  • revertEngine — provides deterministic recovery
  • sessionWatcher — tracks relevant document/session changes
  • superdocsClient — isolates the SuperDocs integration boundary
  • reviewPanel / webviewRender — expose the review experience

Engineering principles

The implementation is deliberately structured around:

  1. Evidence before acceptance
  2. Explicit state rather than implicit mutation
  3. Deterministic checks for safety-critical behavior
  4. Auditable decisions and history
  5. Reversible document operations
  6. Clear separation between core logic, persistence, integration,
    and presentation

Documentation

The use case includes dedicated documentation covering:

  • evaluation
  • implementation planning
  • architecture and capability gaps
  • security considerations

This makes the implementation boundaries and remaining limitations
explicit rather than presenting an incomplete integration as a
production platform.

Validation

The submission includes its own TypeScript configuration, Vitest
configuration, source implementation, and focused test suite.

Scope

This PR is intentionally isolated to:

use-cases/Vishwak-8055/agent-review/

No unrelated files in the SuperDocs builds repository are modified.

Credit

Built and engineered by Vishwak.

@Vishwak-8055 Vishwak-8055 changed the title Add Agent Review: Evidence-Driven Document Change Intelligence Agent Review: Auditable Review Intelligence for Document Workflows Aug 30, 2026
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant