Eliminate unevaluatedProperties behind a single \ branch

[Vansh-kap-98]

unevaluated_properties_to_additional_properties only fires when
unevaluatedProperties has no applicator sibling at all, which does not happen
on real schemas. All 33 unevaluatedProperties occurrences in the OMC benchmark
sit next to allOf: [ { $ref } ], so the keyword survives canonicalisation.

This handles that shape. Based on arXiv:2503.11288v1 ("Elimination of annotation
dependencies in validation for Modern JSON Schema"), which I read for this: it is
the paper's cheapest non-trivial case, where a single branch means there is
nothing to intersect and the referenced schema's evaluated property set is
exactly the names its properties spells out.

Renaming alone would be wrong, since additionalProperties only consults
syntactically adjacent properties/patternProperties and the $ref's
properties are not adjacent. The referenced names are merged into the local
properties as true schemas first; validation still comes from the untouched
$ref.

The rewrite applies only when the target is statically characterisable: no
in-place applicator or reference of its own, no unevaluated*, no
additionalProperties, no non-empty patternProperties. Targets whose
required is not already covered by properties are skipped, since
required_properties_in_properties would widen them later, as are legacy
dialects, which grow an implicit additionalProperties.

Limits: converts only the terminal hop of a $ref chain (in a -> b -> c only
b -> c), does not touch unevaluatedItems, and does not affect
E2E_Evaluator_*, which compiles the raw schema without canonicalising.

Effect: benchmark/e2e/omc/schema.json goes from 33 unevaluatedProperties to
0 after canonicalisation. No site in benchmark/e2e/openapi/schema.json
converts.

[cubic-dev-ai]

1 issue found across 4 files

Prompt for AI agents (unresolved issues)

Check if these issues are valid — if so, understand the root cause of each and fix them. If appropriate, use sub-agents to investigate and fix each issue separately.


<file name="test/canonicalizer/canonicalizer_2019_09_test.cc">

<violation number="1" location="test/canonicalizer/canonicalizer_2019_09_test.cc:749">
P3: Only the happy path and two negative cases (anyOf target, additionalProperties target) are tested, but the rewrite stays sound only because of several other guard conditions that the PR description explicitly calls out. Add "stays" tests for a target with `required` not fully covered by `properties`, a non-empty `patternProperties`, an in-place applicator such as `items`/`contains`, and a legacy dialect (e.g. draft-04), plus a top-level sibling `unevaluatedItems`. These guard conditions are what prevent the rewrite from corrupting semantics, so leaving them untested hides regressions in exactly the logic this PR exists to add. The rule also applies to 2020-12, so the same cases belong in canonicalizer_2020_12_test.cc.</violation>
</file>

<sub>Reply with feedback, questions, or to request a fix.

Re-trigger cubic</sub>

[cubic-dev-ai]

P3: Only the happy path and two negative cases (anyOf target, additionalProperties target) are tested, but the rewrite stays sound only because of several other guard conditions that the PR description explicitly calls out. Add "stays" tests for a target with required not fully covered by properties, a non-empty patternProperties, an in-place applicator such as items/contains, and a legacy dialect (e.g. draft-04), plus a top-level sibling unevaluatedItems. These guard conditions are what prevent the rewrite from corrupting semantics, so leaving them untested hides regressions in exactly the logic this PR exists to add. The rule also applies to 2020-12, so the same cases belong in canonicalizer_2020_12_test.cc.

Prompt for AI agents

Check if this issue is valid — if so, understand the root cause and fix it. At test/canonicalizer/canonicalizer_2019_09_test.cc, line 749:

<comment>Only the happy path and two negative cases (anyOf target, additionalProperties target) are tested, but the rewrite stays sound only because of several other guard conditions that the PR description explicitly calls out. Add "stays" tests for a target with `required` not fully covered by `properties`, a non-empty `patternProperties`, an in-place applicator such as `items`/`contains`, and a legacy dialect (e.g. draft-04), plus a top-level sibling `unevaluatedItems`. These guard conditions are what prevent the rewrite from corrupting semantics, so leaving them untested hides regressions in exactly the logic this PR exists to add. The rule also applies to 2020-12, so the same cases belong in canonicalizer_2020_12_test.cc.</comment>

<file context>
@@ -746,6 +746,187 @@ TEST(items_implicit_1) {
   CANONICALIZE_AND_VALIDATE(document, expected, compiled_metaschema());
 }
 
+TEST(unevaluated_properties_single_ref_to_additional_properties) {
+  auto document = sourcemeta::core::parse_json(R"JSON({
+    "$schema": "https://json-schema.org/draft/2019-09/schema",
</file context>

[github-actions]

Benchmark (macos/llvm)

Details

Benchmark suite	Current: d6f2e44	Previous: e8b95e6	Ratio
Schema_Tracker_ISO_Language	4895158.171052571 ns/iter	5821227.745341783 ns/iter	0.84
Schema_Tracker_ISO_Language_To_JSON	16562066.108695429 ns/iter	14943911.239131663 ns/iter	1.11
Schema_Frame_WoT_References	6134831.868420957 ns/iter	5574424.169999475 ns/iter	1.10
Schema_Frame_OMC_References	29462961.538460884 ns/iter	27135993.851852957 ns/iter	1.09
Schema_Frame_OMC_Locations	27659177.884616453 ns/iter	22490370.117646523 ns/iter	1.23
Schema_Frame_ISO_Language_Locations	78027703.12498808 ns/iter	78002490.77777405 ns/iter	1.00
Schema_Frame_ISO_Language_Root	221.70657687330763 ns/iter	230.67340799397593 ns/iter	0.96
Schema_Frame_KrakenD_References	51957473.45454617 ns/iter	46250098.21428908 ns/iter	1.12
Schema_Frame_KrakenD_Reachable	603480332.9999932 ns/iter	568496416.0000163 ns/iter	1.06
Schema_Frame_ISO_Language_Locations_To_JSON	145094583.24999967 ns/iter	177218541.59999567 ns/iter	0.82
Schema_Frame_Many_Resources_References	800746708.5000144 ns/iter	744475499.9999646 ns/iter	1.08
Schema_Frame_Deeply_Nested_References	18642883.999998074 ns/iter	19731800.675673626 ns/iter	0.94
Schema_Bundle_Meta_2020_12	1676788.5437507364 ns/iter	1639063.1333360753 ns/iter	1.02
Schema_Format_ISO_Language_To_JSON	98611923.49994023 ns/iter	115518187.66666126 ns/iter	0.85
E2E_Compiler_adaptivecard	69621412.9091004 ns/iter	69120854.25000215 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Compiler_ansible_meta	33303041.65217018 ns/iter	31786611.842101976 ns/iter	1.05
E2E_Compiler_aws_cdk	315805.6727272777 ns/iter	298330.95828169317 ns/iter	1.06
E2E_Compiler_babelrc	2735433.155477416 ns/iter	2107341.923076722 ns/iter	1.30
E2E_Compiler_clang_format	17461507.590910103 ns/iter	19281456.521740813 ns/iter	0.91
E2E_Compiler_cmake_presets	26922185.88461296 ns/iter	29815754.999999627 ns/iter	0.90
E2E_Compiler_code_climate	2156012.3247590717 ns/iter	2219963.5193134896 ns/iter	0.97
E2E_Compiler_cql2	12002619.629033836 ns/iter	13881698.52941255 ns/iter	0.86
E2E_Compiler_cspell	23989915.26666426 ns/iter	26727985.10714155 ns/iter	0.90
E2E_Compiler_cypress	4120089.651686091 ns/iter	5346847.487179328 ns/iter	0.77
E2E_Compiler_deno	7689684.148146378 ns/iter	7991958.860759351 ns/iter	0.96
E2E_Compiler_dependabot	3918667.630057174 ns/iter	4984495.000000304 ns/iter	0.79
E2E_Compiler_draft_04	2192279.6373244855 ns/iter	2682729.8447654843 ns/iter	0.82
E2E_Compiler_fabric_mod	4136243.497109165 ns/iter	3939440.207791715 ns/iter	1.05
E2E_Compiler_geojson	25702084.677416883 ns/iter	20880613.281249795 ns/iter	1.23
E2E_Compiler_gitpod_configuration	4962830.962025277 ns/iter	5284821.061349683 ns/iter	0.94
E2E_Compiler_helm_chart_lock	588813.3077544504 ns/iter	654901.5556734343 ns/iter	0.90
E2E_Compiler_importmap	222207.00034399197 ns/iter	335302.6872428004 ns/iter	0.66
E2E_Compiler_jasmine	1191207.1954020446 ns/iter	1532345.724220847 ns/iter	0.78
E2E_Compiler_jshintrc	3953333.0838323394 ns/iter	5011670.089552455 ns/iter	0.79
E2E_Compiler_jsconfig	24503054.46153869 ns/iter	26421833.310345046 ns/iter	0.93
E2E_Compiler_krakend	150830341.60002172 ns/iter	172995166.66666174 ns/iter	0.87
E2E_Compiler_lazygit	36194713.23529123 ns/iter	37075114.54999803 ns/iter	0.98
E2E_Compiler_lerna	1257320.8648650316 ns/iter	1575986.1623615755 ns/iter	0.80
E2E_Compiler_nest_cli	6221487.85416717 ns/iter	7030606.481482019 ns/iter	0.88
E2E_Compiler_omc	174054500.00001112 ns/iter	209036177.2499989 ns/iter	0.83
E2E_Compiler_omnisharp	6371717.631067953 ns/iter	7462889.231707843 ns/iter	0.85
E2E_Compiler_openapi	29312413.67856988 ns/iter	32144242.29629795 ns/iter	0.91
E2E_Compiler_pre_commit_hooks	5265043.750000587 ns/iter	6103324.519230569 ns/iter	0.86
E2E_Compiler_pulumi	3874097.8023959077 ns/iter	4608453.61635191 ns/iter	0.84
E2E_Compiler_semantic_release	1417168.604040504 ns/iter	1584434.0958605332 ns/iter	0.89
E2E_Compiler_stale	1560174.1071428598 ns/iter	1299528.914046039 ns/iter	1.20
E2E_Compiler_stylecop	6509162.752137823 ns/iter	6509328.457445676 ns/iter	1.00
E2E_Compiler_tmuxinator	1706790.1678658074 ns/iter	1716507.7922075621 ns/iter	0.99
E2E_Compiler_ui5	53695749.999990635 ns/iter	63223838.49999369 ns/iter	0.85
E2E_Compiler_ui5_manifest	337029916.9999953 ns/iter	337363270.99995834 ns/iter	1.00
E2E_Compiler_unreal_engine_uproject	4395968.809815831 ns/iter	5451757.911392242 ns/iter	0.81
E2E_Compiler_users_array	737525.3305525308 ns/iter	810490.7173699506 ns/iter	0.91
E2E_Compiler_vercel	13786400.943397997 ns/iter	13898252.1186424 ns/iter	0.99
E2E_Compiler_yamllint	287571.37334405916 ns/iter	292615.6765345964 ns/iter	0.98
E2E_Evaluator_adaptivecard	27719.39881933084 ns/iter	27224.877621553045 ns/iter	1.02
E2E_Evaluator_ansible_meta	241828.31319757953 ns/iter	252493.65805784936 ns/iter	0.96
E2E_Evaluator_aws_cdk	53194.665132506954 ns/iter	54531.19172364653 ns/iter	0.98
E2E_Evaluator_babelrc	116054.46828565343 ns/iter	122172.05798721442 ns/iter	0.95
E2E_Evaluator_cerebrum_criminal_case	1230786.4744406005 ns/iter	1226278.6651482102 ns/iter	1.00
E2E_Evaluator_clang_format	116957.51538236487 ns/iter	117410.14011148027 ns/iter	1.00
E2E_Evaluator_cmake_presets	5198224.942029046 ns/iter	4367700.241176836 ns/iter	1.19
E2E_Evaluator_code_climate	214648.0922714793 ns/iter	187398.87456631023 ns/iter	1.15
E2E_Evaluator_cql2	239103.31905146202 ns/iter	199065.28662418775 ns/iter	1.20
E2E_Evaluator_cspell	636591.9549783963 ns/iter	586671.0830000556 ns/iter	1.09
E2E_Evaluator_cypress	181747.01115830752 ns/iter	171986.55792018466 ns/iter	1.06
E2E_Evaluator_deno	355886.9073148361 ns/iter	416092.1719890431 ns/iter	0.86
E2E_Evaluator_dependabot	368611.1523021467 ns/iter	512632.04225353297 ns/iter	0.72
E2E_Evaluator_draft_04	6182889.547169838 ns/iter	8721341.549296124 ns/iter	0.71
E2E_Evaluator_fabric_mod	530904.0608107989 ns/iter	834655.832760548 ns/iter	0.64
E2E_Evaluator_geojson	9964514.96153802 ns/iter	12981102.678570064 ns/iter	0.77
E2E_Evaluator_gitpod_configuration	210053.46596204542 ns/iter	300266.7756553673 ns/iter	0.70
E2E_Evaluator_helm_chart_lock	293012.84954702185 ns/iter	444961.6837232444 ns/iter	0.66
E2E_Evaluator_importmap	43861.864717871074 ns/iter	66886.44935345773 ns/iter	0.66
E2E_Evaluator_jasmine	100936.00778210993 ns/iter	169089.33491542537 ns/iter	0.60
E2E_Evaluator_jshintrc	955154.6489797612 ns/iter	1410532.1936839526 ns/iter	0.68
E2E_Evaluator_jsconfig	329839.37213655957 ns/iter	548706.7909998586 ns/iter	0.60
E2E_Evaluator_krakend	151655.30218772852 ns/iter	253511.96369641589 ns/iter	0.60
E2E_Evaluator_lazygit	137520.69581629403 ns/iter	186014.33154950553 ns/iter	0.74
E2E_Evaluator_lerna	158682.94604043657 ns/iter	234139.54904589642 ns/iter	0.68
E2E_Evaluator_nest_cli	162276.97265712838 ns/iter	238445.9470845934 ns/iter	0.68
E2E_Evaluator_omc	16789.564300927046 ns/iter	24782.455290383143 ns/iter	0.68
E2E_Evaluator_omnisharp	518555.0000001058 ns/iter	731738.4217626797 ns/iter	0.71
E2E_Evaluator_openapi	8032790.6626510415 ns/iter	12571743.644068222 ns/iter	0.64
E2E_Evaluator_pre_commit_hooks	401228.66705671325 ns/iter	627913.2145816545 ns/iter	0.64
E2E_Evaluator_pulumi	598957.9497906779 ns/iter	775888.1528471564 ns/iter	0.77
E2E_Evaluator_semantic_release	86090.66425064548 ns/iter	109901.18103047911 ns/iter	0.78
E2E_Evaluator_stale	155572.18099442055 ns/iter	175199.14353584775 ns/iter	0.89
E2E_Evaluator_stylecop	222282.12414030446 ns/iter	284844.2081384533 ns/iter	0.78
E2E_Evaluator_tmuxinator	79016.66663043294 ns/iter	117011.30783133506 ns/iter	0.68
E2E_Evaluator_ui5	404777.87214332906 ns/iter	608070.9964538635 ns/iter	0.67
E2E_Evaluator_ui5_manifest	3133330.2631577556 ns/iter	3218597.2248065136 ns/iter	0.97
E2E_Evaluator_unreal_engine_uproject	599265.276893671 ns/iter	561585.0839999438 ns/iter	1.07
E2E_Evaluator_users_array	595727.3750000241 ns/iter	891776.4539614788 ns/iter	0.67
E2E_Evaluator_vercel	299207.0089147606 ns/iter	296874.55043585756 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Evaluator_yamllint	11735.279306442359 ns/iter	10844.509700992523 ns/iter	1.08
JSONLD_Catalog_Simple	22077236.1249999 ns/iter	19970442.225800775 ns/iter	1.11
JSONLD_Catalog_Override_Agreeing	22875347.23332859 ns/iter	22702118.033331923 ns/iter	1.01
JSONLD_Catalog_Override_Shadowing	32221041.666667182 ns/iter	29931651.63999947 ns/iter	1.08
Micro_Draft4_Meta_1_No_Callback	173.12805007389403 ns/iter	181.10936780107627 ns/iter	0.96
Micro_Draft4_Required_Properties	820.6377379612585 ns/iter	782.8344604277877 ns/iter	1.05
Micro_Draft4_Many_Optional_Properties_Minimal_Match	30.889008744437632 ns/iter	20.2992864789032 ns/iter	1.52
Micro_Draft4_Few_Optional_Properties_Minimal_Match	12.410972515230043 ns/iter	10.659154590212372 ns/iter	1.16
Micro_Draft4_Items_Schema	346.575735704572 ns/iter	290.99085629636903 ns/iter	1.19
Micro_Draft4_Nested_Object	1.1737155982775869 ns/iter	1.0836414115272865 ns/iter	1.08
Micro_Draft4_Properties_Triad_Optional	325.0900488343117 ns/iter	267.8929671902664 ns/iter	1.21
Micro_Draft4_Properties_Triad_Closed	358.17680068805424 ns/iter	205.29990009437947 ns/iter	1.74
Micro_Draft4_Properties_Triad_Required	369.2803175487412 ns/iter	278.51795343876535 ns/iter	1.33
Micro_Draft4_Properties_Closed	59.22255219859594 ns/iter	53.52634701525987 ns/iter	1.11
Micro_Draft4_Non_Recursive_Ref	16.05357572066963 ns/iter	12.935106968780689 ns/iter	1.24
Micro_Draft4_Pattern_Properties_Empty	174.59847982495995 ns/iter	154.64443317903746 ns/iter	1.13
Micro_Draft4_Ref_To_Single_Property	11.039394044222314 ns/iter	14.738587990618916 ns/iter	0.75
Micro_Draft4_Additional_Properties_Type	40.38540235894617 ns/iter	34.465894131796524 ns/iter	1.17
Micro_Draft4_Nested_Oneof	45.71364636738957 ns/iter	40.56755188702003 ns/iter	1.13
Micro_Draft4_Short_Enum	5.3661945067771715 ns/iter	5.182536553304349 ns/iter	1.04
Micro_Draft4_Long_Enum	11.426617624265724 ns/iter	11.641941423885982 ns/iter	0.98
Micro_Draft4_Long_Enum_Short_Strings	6.686480829804248 ns/iter	7.296306517556745 ns/iter	0.92
Micro_Draft4_Type_Object	2.440177058334498 ns/iter	2.9563402069545193 ns/iter	0.83
Micro_Draft4_Ref_Single_100	1446620.4081632637 ns/iter	1821288.5542170515 ns/iter	0.79
Micro_Draft4_Compile_Ref_Many_Nested	982645.7975566685 ns/iter	1124458.3984375112 ns/iter	0.87
Micro_Draft4_Compile_Wrap	1559938.8322294808 ns/iter	1658846.8486490357 ns/iter	0.94
Micro_Draft6_Property_Names	96.27965608013108 ns/iter	107.98339780190433 ns/iter	0.89
Micro_Draft6_Compile_FHIR	13267263916.99981 ns/iter	18453039875.000057 ns/iter	0.72
Micro_Draft7_If_Then_Else	18.316913918020266 ns/iter	29.35083336734612 ns/iter	0.62
Micro_2019_09_Unevaluated_Properties	28.776947521891618 ns/iter	58.06875320755548 ns/iter	0.50
Micro_2019_09_Compile_Wrap	271073194.6666935 ns/iter	1105265833.0002031 ns/iter	0.25
Micro_2020_12_Dynamic_Ref	601.6635507134582 ns/iter	972.2875926101296 ns/iter	0.62
Micro_2020_12_Dynamic_Ref_Single	2.444262031177673 ns/iter	5.406523886618544 ns/iter	0.45
Micro_2020_12_Simple_Output_Mask	802.9149748011989 ns/iter	1391.4749131117953 ns/iter	0.58
Micro_2020_12_Simple_Output_Annotations	56642.37663372006 ns/iter	99398.32810487553 ns/iter	0.57
Micro_2020_12_Simple_Output_Annotation_Dropping	1179251.4534884584 ns/iter	1980558.1306991095 ns/iter	0.60
Micro_2020_12_Compile_NonCircular_Shared_Refs	669796.8559480485 ns/iter	1150348.6545454434 ns/iter	0.58
Micro_2020_12_Exhaustive_Deep_Numeric	5195.55167000135 ns/iter	8139.149141502669 ns/iter	0.64
Micro_2020_12_Exhaustive_Deep_Numeric_SimpleOutput	30605.3631664194 ns/iter	51304.46018376282 ns/iter	0.60
Micro_2020_12_Exhaustive_Deep_Numeric_TraceOutput	13209.22045215312 ns/iter	19518.310142967388 ns/iter	0.68
Micro_2020_12_Exhaustive_Deep_Numeric_Fail	92.65956651835653 ns/iter	123.89777588892608 ns/iter	0.75
Micro_2020_12_Exhaustive_Deep_Numeric_Fail_SimpleOutput	2479.122797846483 ns/iter	3440.297643789726 ns/iter	0.72
TestSuite_Parse_WoT	19432975.69444111 ns/iter	32771009.04348196 ns/iter	0.59
Alterschema_Check_Readibility_ISO_Language_Set_3	205834152.66666332 ns/iter	329346167.0000397 ns/iter	0.62
Alterschema_Check_Readibility_OMC	65897734.81819479 ns/iter	115677077.42856978 ns/iter	0.57
Alterschema_Check_Readibility_KrakenD	786264834.0001215 ns/iter	1482372333.0000575 ns/iter	0.53
Alterschema_Apply_Readibility_KrakenD	95035252416.00005 ns/iter	137948064541.00012 ns/iter	0.69
Alterschema_Check_Invalid_External_Refs	197338395.99996373 ns/iter	218196139.00000453 ns/iter	0.90

This comment was automatically generated by workflow using github-action-benchmark.

[github-actions]

JavaScript (macos/llvm)

Details

Benchmark suite	Current: d6f2e44	Previous: e8b95e6	Ratio
E2E_Evaluator_adaptivecard	191893 ns	149154 ns	1.29
E2E_Evaluator_ansible-meta	653335 ns	502872 ns	1.30
E2E_Evaluator_aws-cdk	161045 ns	165572 ns	0.97
E2E_Evaluator_babelrc	427933 ns	406072 ns	1.05
E2E_Evaluator_cerebrum-criminal-case	2545579 ns	2311479 ns	1.10
E2E_Evaluator_clang-format	260839 ns	238950 ns	1.09
E2E_Evaluator_cmake-presets	17435462 ns	16770373 ns	1.04
E2E_Evaluator_code-climate	597512 ns	498603 ns	1.20
E2E_Evaluator_cql2	1243145 ns	1432801 ns	0.87
E2E_Evaluator_cspell	1704249 ns	1816423 ns	0.94
E2E_Evaluator_cypress	872841 ns	774250 ns	1.13
E2E_Evaluator_deno	893037 ns	1190868 ns	0.75
E2E_Evaluator_dependabot	914710 ns	1037945 ns	0.88
E2E_Evaluator_draft-04	19487018 ns	21925400 ns	0.89
E2E_Evaluator_fabric-mod	1954853 ns	2488411 ns	0.79
E2E_Evaluator_geojson	17921603 ns	22573303 ns	0.79
E2E_Evaluator_gitpod-configuration	527401 ns	626068 ns	0.84
E2E_Evaluator_helm-chart-lock	876628 ns	1045529 ns	0.84
E2E_Evaluator_importmap	238689 ns	240601 ns	0.99
E2E_Evaluator_jasmine	308232 ns	252747 ns	1.22
E2E_Evaluator_jsconfig	1095683 ns	999148 ns	1.10
E2E_Evaluator_jshintrc	2688319 ns	2712259 ns	0.99
E2E_Evaluator_krakend	486459 ns	518268 ns	0.94
E2E_Evaluator_lazygit	344628 ns	345845 ns	1.00
E2E_Evaluator_lerna	367958 ns	368008 ns	1.00
E2E_Evaluator_nest-cli	516891 ns	482723 ns	1.07
E2E_Evaluator_omc	107218 ns	105353 ns	1.02
E2E_Evaluator_omnisharp	1185388 ns	1173692 ns	1.01
E2E_Evaluator_openapi	30318269 ns	34546013 ns	0.88
E2E_Evaluator_pre-commit-hooks	1573748 ns	1722749 ns	0.91
E2E_Evaluator_pulumi	1553939 ns	1744217 ns	0.89
E2E_Evaluator_semantic-release	176256 ns	194941 ns	0.90
E2E_Evaluator_stale	289162 ns	360651 ns	0.80
E2E_Evaluator_stylecop	717162 ns	876056 ns	0.82
E2E_Evaluator_tmuxinator	182239 ns	207299 ns	0.88
E2E_Evaluator_ui5	1665406 ns	1748910 ns	0.95
E2E_Evaluator_ui5-manifest	7971960 ns	13011115 ns	0.61
E2E_Evaluator_unreal-engine-uproject	1147577 ns	1405460 ns	0.82
E2E_Evaluator_users-array	2378763 ns	2801879 ns	0.85
E2E_Evaluator_vercel	771676 ns	957311 ns	0.81
E2E_Evaluator_yamllint	25040 ns	29638 ns	0.84

This comment was automatically generated by workflow using github-action-benchmark.

[github-actions]

Benchmark (linux/llvm)

Details

Benchmark suite	Current: d6f2e44	Previous: e8b95e6	Ratio
Schema_Tracker_ISO_Language	3522804.6515149944 ns/iter	3647622.441624358 ns/iter	0.97
Schema_Tracker_ISO_Language_To_JSON	15005222.782608895 ns/iter	14899313.61702039 ns/iter	1.01
Schema_Frame_WoT_References	3256276.8472219943 ns/iter	3194058.457398822 ns/iter	1.02
Schema_Frame_OMC_References	14671794.723402312 ns/iter	14494854.854165832 ns/iter	1.01
Schema_Frame_OMC_Locations	13595213.90195948 ns/iter	13372525.250000186 ns/iter	1.02
Schema_Frame_ISO_Language_Locations	69707986.89999357 ns/iter	66318985.39999384 ns/iter	1.05
Schema_Frame_ISO_Language_Root	261.7407041709218 ns/iter	254.58042570680573 ns/iter	1.03
Schema_Frame_KrakenD_References	28171097.999997985 ns/iter	27456353.12000104 ns/iter	1.03
Schema_Frame_KrakenD_Reachable	418177591.5000117 ns/iter	405620175.50001884 ns/iter	1.03
Schema_Frame_ISO_Language_Locations_To_JSON	160365785.75000247 ns/iter	158002590.74998733 ns/iter	1.01
Schema_Frame_Many_Resources_References	277899175.3333457 ns/iter	269910975.66667575 ns/iter	1.03
Schema_Frame_Deeply_Nested_References	9043091.28947333 ns/iter	9017393.077922495 ns/iter	1.00
Schema_Bundle_Meta_2020_12	889554.4099611167 ns/iter	889144.3642148532 ns/iter	1.00
Schema_Format_ISO_Language_To_JSON	73667482.77777585 ns/iter	69658260.44442262 ns/iter	1.06
E2E_Compiler_adaptivecard	41395870.11764648 ns/iter	40391964.72221976 ns/iter	1.02
E2E_Compiler_ansible_meta	18025886.282051336 ns/iter	17758583.124998495 ns/iter	1.02
E2E_Compiler_aws_cdk	199267.12673268066 ns/iter	193703.2371618015 ns/iter	1.03
E2E_Compiler_babelrc	1532871.1873636723 ns/iter	1488346.7876856783 ns/iter	1.03
E2E_Compiler_clang_format	11576513.450000903 ns/iter	11421026.721312374 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Compiler_cmake_presets	18595394.31579175 ns/iter	18346951.473682493 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Compiler_code_climate	1535226.1768559034 ns/iter	1490474.04680856 ns/iter	1.03
E2E_Compiler_cql2	8996679.987179644 ns/iter	8817776.125000875 ns/iter	1.02
E2E_Compiler_cspell	16644176.809523156 ns/iter	15931728.046510661 ns/iter	1.04
E2E_Compiler_cypress	2654019.401515312 ns/iter	2653294.465908764 ns/iter	1.00
E2E_Compiler_deno	4954184.770833573 ns/iter	4855488.645833677 ns/iter	1.02
E2E_Compiler_dependabot	2387119.1672354797 ns/iter	2370615.87118637 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Compiler_draft_04	1603513.3672057341 ns/iter	1590990.7823127485 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Compiler_fabric_mod	2845881.4612242943 ns/iter	2806987.705645545 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Compiler_geojson	14838905.520832667 ns/iter	14655706.04166781 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Compiler_gitpod_configuration	3103727.906666589 ns/iter	3021162.5948276115 ns/iter	1.03
E2E_Compiler_helm_chart_lock	378708.2847109781 ns/iter	384245.59078877076 ns/iter	0.99
E2E_Compiler_importmap	154915.47876105964 ns/iter	150084.3134996812 ns/iter	1.03
E2E_Compiler_jasmine	759789.9105779363 ns/iter	738472.5126849752 ns/iter	1.03
E2E_Compiler_jshintrc	2562072.133828883 ns/iter	2575355.732852136 ns/iter	0.99
E2E_Compiler_jsconfig	14574868.04166545 ns/iter	14566816.020831652 ns/iter	1.00
E2E_Compiler_krakend	99903815.57143532 ns/iter	95142845.28571741 ns/iter	1.05
E2E_Compiler_lazygit	21699901.34375155 ns/iter	21618750.272726614 ns/iter	1.00
E2E_Compiler_lerna	884841.3837356033 ns/iter	868429.8688726412 ns/iter	1.02
E2E_Compiler_nest_cli	4701239.391891931 ns/iter	4598745.163398948 ns/iter	1.02
E2E_Compiler_omc	107176551.33331998 ns/iter	103652848.66666494 ns/iter	1.03
E2E_Compiler_omnisharp	4263350.642424319 ns/iter	4161337.835294302 ns/iter	1.02
E2E_Compiler_openapi	15799522.477273988 ns/iter	15587447.266665954 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Compiler_pre_commit_hooks	3150789.018018013 ns/iter	3099425.114537713 ns/iter	1.02
E2E_Compiler_pulumi	2478171.1357141896 ns/iter	2449419.0815604036 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Compiler_semantic_release	884772.8432365456 ns/iter	854106.1741779099 ns/iter	1.04
E2E_Compiler_stale	883076.8876261993 ns/iter	852682.4872107592 ns/iter	1.04
E2E_Compiler_stylecop	3657626.4450260596 ns/iter	3607331.051282414 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Compiler_tmuxinator	1052354.879154097 ns/iter	1033969.6611941323 ns/iter	1.02
E2E_Compiler_ui5	32000754.818181 ns/iter	31684033.409093942 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Compiler_ui5_manifest	199853467.33331728 ns/iter	192345956.99996743 ns/iter	1.04
E2E_Compiler_unreal_engine_uproject	2803031.3388430956 ns/iter	2764129.8920002556 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Compiler_users_array	448966.6617172423 ns/iter	437402.55562538916 ns/iter	1.03
E2E_Compiler_vercel	8781210.925000949 ns/iter	8738024.987499671 ns/iter	1.00
E2E_Compiler_yamllint	175705.83726123523 ns/iter	171674.8466633746 ns/iter	1.02
E2E_Evaluator_adaptivecard	18886.037708753847 ns/iter	18225.10630411049 ns/iter	1.04
E2E_Evaluator_ansible_meta	170443.67146340624 ns/iter	171062.10585091906 ns/iter	1.00
E2E_Evaluator_aws_cdk	38465.06956092554 ns/iter	38352.013498623026 ns/iter	1.00
E2E_Evaluator_babelrc	94549.77905911396 ns/iter	90055.14983338311 ns/iter	1.05
E2E_Evaluator_cerebrum_criminal_case	935600.9612299342 ns/iter	929862.7306176111 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Evaluator_clang_format	92689.63031199406 ns/iter	90060.901372331 ns/iter	1.03
E2E_Evaluator_cmake_presets	4112365.192982688 ns/iter	3998416.8742856644 ns/iter	1.03
E2E_Evaluator_code_climate	157115.75488653028 ns/iter	150652.92651826193 ns/iter	1.04
E2E_Evaluator_cql2	150800.73417719806 ns/iter	149679.97219844544 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Evaluator_cspell	532002.2763856576 ns/iter	524237.87658933375 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Evaluator_cypress	154066.9893593425 ns/iter	153373.43142417542 ns/iter	1.00
E2E_Evaluator_deno	305993.3814074572 ns/iter	299832.86007702205 ns/iter	1.02
E2E_Evaluator_dependabot	274876.04741213395 ns/iter	273646.22139496426 ns/iter	1.00
E2E_Evaluator_draft_04	5790722.1111115655 ns/iter	5683457.388430319 ns/iter	1.02
E2E_Evaluator_fabric_mod	604021.8003428286 ns/iter	591829.4725274418 ns/iter	1.02
E2E_Evaluator_geojson	10444078.745763363 ns/iter	8752140.972602904 ns/iter	1.19
E2E_Evaluator_gitpod_configuration	181633.08055995728 ns/iter	181295.79932936825 ns/iter	1.00
E2E_Evaluator_helm_chart_lock	401294.09179023386 ns/iter	392567.51010101626 ns/iter	1.02
E2E_Evaluator_importmap	31177.401817265156 ns/iter	30609.093774763813 ns/iter	1.02
E2E_Evaluator_jasmine	92374.43754113671 ns/iter	91504.108051396 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Evaluator_jshintrc	1045707.0868263358 ns/iter	1032658.0162241366 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Evaluator_jsconfig	325745.9821428487 ns/iter	322340.508965503 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Evaluator_krakend	146758.98383370865 ns/iter	143634.40422045632 ns/iter	1.02
E2E_Evaluator_lazygit	103686.73913687655 ns/iter	102747.79568155111 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Evaluator_lerna	151853.28289331988 ns/iter	150578.03212677708 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Evaluator_nest_cli	145609.4786749371 ns/iter	144829.59046051803 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Evaluator_omc	15275.556835570838 ns/iter	15149.267649611658 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Evaluator_omnisharp	473992.25321602327 ns/iter	470379.87752360204 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Evaluator_openapi	9216822.368421461 ns/iter	8876365.666667541 ns/iter	1.04
E2E_Evaluator_pre_commit_hooks	422651.74271843035 ns/iter	419670.3270971375 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Evaluator_pulumi	662492.7215311169 ns/iter	675153.865294645 ns/iter	0.98
E2E_Evaluator_semantic_release	74393.68456376721 ns/iter	72254.08171975962 ns/iter	1.03
E2E_Evaluator_stale	122286.77418215216 ns/iter	120660.44878305244 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Evaluator_stylecop	211174.68300850946 ns/iter	210620.23764147406 ns/iter	1.00
E2E_Evaluator_tmuxinator	78171.91642840797 ns/iter	76436.03965141036 ns/iter	1.02
E2E_Evaluator_ui5	379075.6910880084 ns/iter	374883.5512958959 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Evaluator_ui5_manifest	2224090.531250056 ns/iter	2186475.7089783936 ns/iter	1.02
E2E_Evaluator_unreal_engine_uproject	380044.9277566339 ns/iter	372148.5586681029 ns/iter	1.02
E2E_Evaluator_users_array	526382.379746803 ns/iter	515204.3179448781 ns/iter	1.02
E2E_Evaluator_vercel	286542.74959082843 ns/iter	280651.818145474 ns/iter	1.02
E2E_Evaluator_yamllint	6416.98885157568 ns/iter	6315.562353199448 ns/iter	1.02
JSONLD_Catalog_Simple	14905587.645832459 ns/iter	14114663.55101979 ns/iter	1.06
JSONLD_Catalog_Override_Agreeing	14801393.212765783 ns/iter	14531438.500000603 ns/iter	1.02
JSONLD_Catalog_Override_Shadowing	23502083.100000463 ns/iter	23675119.73333573 ns/iter	0.99
Micro_Draft4_Meta_1_No_Callback	139.25831794887443 ns/iter	137.88084613929914 ns/iter	1.01
Micro_Draft4_Required_Properties	594.090418171726 ns/iter	591.4859713611602 ns/iter	1.00
Micro_Draft4_Many_Optional_Properties_Minimal_Match	17.727485034270888 ns/iter	17.957407485839095 ns/iter	0.99
Micro_Draft4_Few_Optional_Properties_Minimal_Match	8.1072896615181 ns/iter	8.074915588722162 ns/iter	1.00
Micro_Draft4_Items_Schema	260.45826069692583 ns/iter	256.68632386175597 ns/iter	1.01
Micro_Draft4_Nested_Object	1.1031082195505346 ns/iter	1.10300569498006 ns/iter	1.00
Micro_Draft4_Properties_Triad_Optional	247.5309164438059 ns/iter	248.2991187180465 ns/iter	1.00
Micro_Draft4_Properties_Triad_Closed	204.05547358766137 ns/iter	203.47152523928898 ns/iter	1.00
Micro_Draft4_Properties_Triad_Required	256.7331702977121 ns/iter	255.3230654729455 ns/iter	1.01
Micro_Draft4_Properties_Closed	48.57100723365265 ns/iter	48.113247294733284 ns/iter	1.01
Micro_Draft4_Non_Recursive_Ref	11.750637160248292 ns/iter	11.682347565460471 ns/iter	1.01
Micro_Draft4_Pattern_Properties_Empty	124.03917595526038 ns/iter	122.89425896205442 ns/iter	1.01
Micro_Draft4_Ref_To_Single_Property	8.099672045876293 ns/iter	8.043408371788692 ns/iter	1.01
Micro_Draft4_Additional_Properties_Type	31.199741682977553 ns/iter	31.03848660266727 ns/iter	1.01
Micro_Draft4_Nested_Oneof	44.689143748475104 ns/iter	43.808082928134624 ns/iter	1.02
Micro_Draft4_Short_Enum	8.466906326039426 ns/iter	8.146182157454321 ns/iter	1.04
Micro_Draft4_Long_Enum	11.745487048315137 ns/iter	11.749778791913894 ns/iter	1.00
Micro_Draft4_Long_Enum_Short_Strings	8.452456652678805 ns/iter	8.130262946590754 ns/iter	1.04
Micro_Draft4_Type_Object	2.771639639781608 ns/iter	2.7748350510293887 ns/iter	1.00
Micro_Draft4_Ref_Single_100	1424183.425661858 ns/iter	1409078.1696968589 ns/iter	1.01
Micro_Draft4_Compile_Ref_Many_Nested	967208.8252426749 ns/iter	962778.2949246964 ns/iter	1.00
Micro_Draft4_Compile_Wrap	1415525.1801618969 ns/iter	1411774.5513078875 ns/iter	1.00
Micro_Draft6_Property_Names	132.40689502738888 ns/iter	131.50346622500368 ns/iter	1.01
Micro_Draft6_Compile_FHIR	12594041317.000006 ns/iter	13335856717.999945 ns/iter	0.94
Micro_Draft7_If_Then_Else	20.831677784357588 ns/iter	20.67852279625573 ns/iter	1.01
Micro_2019_09_Unevaluated_Properties	24.228520188543676 ns/iter	24.18122076952617 ns/iter	1.00
Micro_2019_09_Compile_Wrap	207163354.99999633 ns/iter	204847035.6666788 ns/iter	1.01
Micro_2020_12_Dynamic_Ref	561.2528901219787 ns/iter	556.5209279977695 ns/iter	1.01
Micro_2020_12_Dynamic_Ref_Single	2.4825924799596546 ns/iter	2.4649439849451986 ns/iter	1.01
Micro_2020_12_Simple_Output_Mask	770.4840265127739 ns/iter	749.6790077729229 ns/iter	1.03
Micro_2020_12_Simple_Output_Annotations	39897.24912941559 ns/iter	39741.8693284917 ns/iter	1.00
Micro_2020_12_Simple_Output_Annotation_Dropping	1038441.3594674389 ns/iter	1042159.6775147693 ns/iter	1.00
Micro_2020_12_Compile_NonCircular_Shared_Refs	566102.1813803916 ns/iter	553530.8712479874 ns/iter	1.02
Micro_2020_12_Exhaustive_Deep_Numeric	6004.351456831356 ns/iter	5981.665575865961 ns/iter	1.00
Micro_2020_12_Exhaustive_Deep_Numeric_SimpleOutput	28310.073848541993 ns/iter	28204.689624688144 ns/iter	1.00
Micro_2020_12_Exhaustive_Deep_Numeric_TraceOutput	13822.675553371513 ns/iter	13682.2190137556 ns/iter	1.01
Micro_2020_12_Exhaustive_Deep_Numeric_Fail	100.24423150491371 ns/iter	98.58833339540374 ns/iter	1.02
Micro_2020_12_Exhaustive_Deep_Numeric_Fail_SimpleOutput	1856.8084688978536 ns/iter	1846.849901200762 ns/iter	1.01
TestSuite_Parse_WoT	16193127.604651637 ns/iter	15959372.749999933 ns/iter	1.01
Alterschema_Check_Readibility_ISO_Language_Set_3	258083656.00001553 ns/iter	250472667.33330765 ns/iter	1.03
Alterschema_Check_Readibility_OMC	72925773.70000117 ns/iter	70734455.40000875 ns/iter	1.03
Alterschema_Check_Readibility_KrakenD	1085830675.000011 ns/iter	1052340587.9999927 ns/iter	1.03
Alterschema_Apply_Readibility_KrakenD	114422267318.99995 ns/iter	109767534681.00003 ns/iter	1.04
Alterschema_Check_Invalid_External_Refs	168476757.7499997 ns/iter	160660142.49997807 ns/iter	1.05

This comment was automatically generated by workflow using github-action-benchmark.

[github-actions]

JavaScript (linux/llvm)

Details

Benchmark suite	Current: d6f2e44	Previous: e8b95e6	Ratio
E2E_Evaluator_adaptivecard	92981 ns	91375 ns	1.02
E2E_Evaluator_ansible-meta	393532 ns	375467 ns	1.05
E2E_Evaluator_aws-cdk	118139 ns	111562 ns	1.06
E2E_Evaluator_babelrc	310470 ns	289023 ns	1.07
E2E_Evaluator_cerebrum-criminal-case	1971545 ns	1763866 ns	1.12
E2E_Evaluator_clang-format	218610 ns	196945 ns	1.11
E2E_Evaluator_cmake-presets	15178888 ns	13351196 ns	1.14
E2E_Evaluator_code-climate	492574 ns	433213 ns	1.14
E2E_Evaluator_cql2	1001905 ns	874379 ns	1.15
E2E_Evaluator_cspell	1598053 ns	1220472 ns	1.31
E2E_Evaluator_cypress	823930 ns	686126 ns	1.20
E2E_Evaluator_deno	946281 ns	845221 ns	1.12
E2E_Evaluator_dependabot	906203 ns	819869 ns	1.11
E2E_Evaluator_draft-04	15994446 ns	15075139 ns	1.06
E2E_Evaluator_fabric-mod	2027003 ns	1775835 ns	1.14
E2E_Evaluator_geojson	17969441 ns	15901162 ns	1.13
E2E_Evaluator_gitpod-configuration	629746 ns	533683 ns	1.18
E2E_Evaluator_helm-chart-lock	878242 ns	863997 ns	1.02
E2E_Evaluator_importmap	287554 ns	270002 ns	1.07
E2E_Evaluator_jasmine	229297 ns	212917 ns	1.08
E2E_Evaluator_jsconfig	1219550 ns	1071872 ns	1.14
E2E_Evaluator_jshintrc	2799459 ns	2504394 ns	1.12
E2E_Evaluator_krakend	492142 ns	484110 ns	1.02
E2E_Evaluator_lazygit	395608 ns	338734 ns	1.17
E2E_Evaluator_lerna	410314 ns	371480 ns	1.10
E2E_Evaluator_nest-cli	501602 ns	444289 ns	1.13
E2E_Evaluator_omc	90038 ns	89477 ns	1.01
E2E_Evaluator_omnisharp	1356993 ns	1134404 ns	1.20
E2E_Evaluator_openapi	32273198 ns	28693454 ns	1.12
E2E_Evaluator_pre-commit-hooks	1864298 ns	1526608 ns	1.22
E2E_Evaluator_pulumi	1934218 ns	1514602 ns	1.28
E2E_Evaluator_semantic-release	212791 ns	194514 ns	1.09
E2E_Evaluator_stale	330592 ns	299771 ns	1.10
E2E_Evaluator_stylecop	1137252 ns	942905 ns	1.21
E2E_Evaluator_tmuxinator	206309 ns	191742 ns	1.08
E2E_Evaluator_ui5	1646265 ns	1595506 ns	1.03
E2E_Evaluator_ui5-manifest	8257431 ns	8079457 ns	1.02
E2E_Evaluator_unreal-engine-uproject	1407386 ns	1231796 ns	1.14
E2E_Evaluator_users-array	2687991 ns	2450252 ns	1.10
E2E_Evaluator_vercel	906885 ns	829974 ns	1.09
E2E_Evaluator_yamllint	20665 ns	18778 ns	1.10

This comment was automatically generated by workflow using github-action-benchmark.

[github-actions]

Benchmark (linux/gcc)

Details

Benchmark suite	Current: d6f2e44	Previous: e8b95e6	Ratio
Alterschema_Check_Readibility_ISO_Language_Set_3	312645404.99978465 ns/iter	342758116.500022 ns/iter	0.91
Alterschema_Check_Readibility_OMC	82580467.37500991 ns/iter	84370978.37500574 ns/iter	0.98
Alterschema_Check_Readibility_KrakenD	1039467020.9998367 ns/iter	1037617045.999923 ns/iter	1.00
Alterschema_Apply_Readibility_KrakenD	114425319693.00035 ns/iter	118861007460.99988 ns/iter	0.96
Alterschema_Check_Invalid_External_Refs	284883847.9999358 ns/iter	292627141.9999011 ns/iter	0.97
TestSuite_Parse_WoT	22259395.687498797 ns/iter	22746825.419355974 ns/iter	0.98
Micro_2020_12_Dynamic_Ref	976.1835851622378 ns/iter	975.4580667479244 ns/iter	1.00
Micro_2020_12_Dynamic_Ref_Single	4.3596545845843035 ns/iter	4.363127685915631 ns/iter	1.00
Micro_2020_12_Simple_Output_Mask	1226.1379807725384 ns/iter	1222.6878341277395 ns/iter	1.00
Micro_2020_12_Simple_Output_Annotations	59081.85660253544 ns/iter	59662.031231128094 ns/iter	0.99
Micro_2020_12_Simple_Output_Annotation_Dropping	1617336.0762127703 ns/iter	1643932.9488374041 ns/iter	0.98
Micro_2020_12_Compile_NonCircular_Shared_Refs	870900.6926889652 ns/iter	888507.5083013492 ns/iter	0.98
Micro_2020_12_Exhaustive_Deep_Numeric	9186.566013849653 ns/iter	9203.491108883434 ns/iter	1.00
Micro_2020_12_Exhaustive_Deep_Numeric_SimpleOutput	43923.08574114216 ns/iter	44482.58468692577 ns/iter	0.99
Micro_2020_12_Exhaustive_Deep_Numeric_TraceOutput	22051.782753155574 ns/iter	22335.154368775748 ns/iter	0.99
Micro_2020_12_Exhaustive_Deep_Numeric_Fail	173.87097451855212 ns/iter	170.07926975109143 ns/iter	1.02
Micro_2020_12_Exhaustive_Deep_Numeric_Fail_SimpleOutput	2837.990618090194 ns/iter	2940.413636325347 ns/iter	0.97
Micro_2019_09_Unevaluated_Properties	32.00776136226242 ns/iter	31.78703767727177 ns/iter	1.01
Micro_2019_09_Compile_Wrap	279583348.5001822 ns/iter	302681353.0000254 ns/iter	0.92
Micro_Draft7_If_Then_Else	23.996643706122885 ns/iter	23.98022180794931 ns/iter	1.00
Micro_Draft6_Property_Names	156.3618926048732 ns/iter	156.4377812028024 ns/iter	1.00
Micro_Draft6_Compile_FHIR	11319221500.000366 ns/iter	11647998737.999842 ns/iter	0.97
Micro_Draft4_Meta_1_No_Callback	194.39472009092432 ns/iter	198.1035399585124 ns/iter	0.98
Micro_Draft4_Required_Properties	881.005979880401 ns/iter	865.2333934360697 ns/iter	1.02
Micro_Draft4_Many_Optional_Properties_Minimal_Match	22.19325797763671 ns/iter	22.128764239476375 ns/iter	1.00
Micro_Draft4_Few_Optional_Properties_Minimal_Match	16.51866445371083 ns/iter	16.51271720251497 ns/iter	1.00
Micro_Draft4_Items_Schema	347.50694615957985 ns/iter	352.6640301722841 ns/iter	0.99
Micro_Draft4_Nested_Object	1.5602794057436014 ns/iter	1.5560250402817708 ns/iter	1.00
Micro_Draft4_Properties_Triad_Optional	382.2816819148719 ns/iter	376.1511847485195 ns/iter	1.02
Micro_Draft4_Properties_Triad_Closed	306.35801520243353 ns/iter	310.7496420951127 ns/iter	0.99
Micro_Draft4_Properties_Triad_Required	457.54296942112563 ns/iter	421.68504857854464 ns/iter	1.09
Micro_Draft4_Properties_Closed	64.55796127955149 ns/iter	64.57856361187531 ns/iter	1.00
Micro_Draft4_Non_Recursive_Ref	9.028991121614542 ns/iter	9.095420952856117 ns/iter	0.99
Micro_Draft4_Pattern_Properties_Empty	212.41035422997064 ns/iter	212.58601790554843 ns/iter	1.00
Micro_Draft4_Ref_To_Single_Property	16.84658986664916 ns/iter	16.83991711733345 ns/iter	1.00
Micro_Draft4_Additional_Properties_Type	14.00920218903424 ns/iter	14.01453615939056 ns/iter	1.00
Micro_Draft4_Nested_Oneof	65.98155719521691 ns/iter	66.01213848627579 ns/iter	1.00
Micro_Draft4_Short_Enum	14.683776984714271 ns/iter	14.690222119231944 ns/iter	1.00
Micro_Draft4_Long_Enum	14.337377557121185 ns/iter	14.334600449837016 ns/iter	1.00
Micro_Draft4_Long_Enum_Short_Strings	14.744091318131224 ns/iter	14.690227503818598 ns/iter	1.00
Micro_Draft4_Type_Object	4.358046670742608 ns/iter	4.357945369021947 ns/iter	1.00
Micro_Draft4_Ref_Single_100	1964199.1564248956 ns/iter	2003815.2413797264 ns/iter	0.98
Micro_Draft4_Compile_Ref_Many_Nested	1345938.347490944 ns/iter	1382476.0297026867 ns/iter	0.97
Micro_Draft4_Compile_Wrap	2081016.5934719506 ns/iter	2137553.1489356225 ns/iter	0.97
JSONLD_Catalog_Simple	22705790.129029702 ns/iter	25139091.655170165 ns/iter	0.90
JSONLD_Catalog_Override_Agreeing	21979143.000011858 ns/iter	25445659.481479026 ns/iter	0.86
JSONLD_Catalog_Override_Shadowing	32987289.85713578 ns/iter	36395397.05263336 ns/iter	0.91
E2E_Compiler_adaptivecard	55926507.58334609 ns/iter	58935063.333327286 ns/iter	0.95
E2E_Compiler_ansible_meta	26449338.185186744 ns/iter	27035982.73077345 ns/iter	0.98
E2E_Compiler_aws_cdk	321410.08886848716 ns/iter	330658.2748703578 ns/iter	0.97
E2E_Compiler_babelrc	2189079.0343746855 ns/iter	2227607.8507939163 ns/iter	0.98
E2E_Compiler_clang_format	15940318.61363667 ns/iter	16237920.833332065 ns/iter	0.98
E2E_Compiler_cmake_presets	23654159.433332704 ns/iter	24606280.72413658 ns/iter	0.96
E2E_Compiler_code_climate	2156515.179012224 ns/iter	2184320.3228834732 ns/iter	0.99
E2E_Compiler_cql2	11765433.633339247 ns/iter	12179052.58181831 ns/iter	0.97
E2E_Compiler_cspell	20394127.79999371 ns/iter	21180799.382350683 ns/iter	0.96
E2E_Compiler_cypress	3476643.597016154 ns/iter	3534064.82323256 ns/iter	0.98
E2E_Compiler_deno	7188993.51546291 ns/iter	7342531.291667361 ns/iter	0.98
E2E_Compiler_dependabot	3447578.529412389 ns/iter	3480970.8514850885 ns/iter	0.99
E2E_Compiler_draft_04	2321787.07973499 ns/iter	2360756.5218851725 ns/iter	0.98
E2E_Compiler_fabric_mod	3982655.6704554153 ns/iter	4030673.6589593515 ns/iter	0.99
E2E_Compiler_geojson	20238933.771439146 ns/iter	20575738.382349834 ns/iter	0.98
E2E_Compiler_gitpod_configuration	4285769.243901219 ns/iter	4373066.687500682 ns/iter	0.98
E2E_Compiler_helm_chart_lock	584329.7366667836 ns/iter	594379.9033078837 ns/iter	0.98
E2E_Compiler_importmap	245405.52834161677 ns/iter	251943.6370262494 ns/iter	0.97
E2E_Compiler_jasmine	1125370.0739552658 ns/iter	1148030.852892431 ns/iter	0.98
E2E_Compiler_jshintrc	3698203.675531039 ns/iter	3789252.597825858 ns/iter	0.98
E2E_Compiler_jsconfig	20257903.59999259 ns/iter	20646491.41175992 ns/iter	0.98
E2E_Compiler_krakend	128932955.3999778 ns/iter	135531114.40000975 ns/iter	0.95
E2E_Compiler_lazygit	29787795.782617055 ns/iter	30707003.227276303 ns/iter	0.97
E2E_Compiler_lerna	1356573.3294577273 ns/iter	1384293.7405189185 ns/iter	0.98
E2E_Compiler_nest_cli	6503591.203702988 ns/iter	6631386.999998497 ns/iter	0.98
E2E_Compiler_omc	153494573.99997845 ns/iter	159351166.75001383 ns/iter	0.96
E2E_Compiler_omnisharp	5923818.386553411 ns/iter	6076378.478260464 ns/iter	0.97
E2E_Compiler_openapi	22550099.774185408 ns/iter	23021799.099994194 ns/iter	0.98
E2E_Compiler_pre_commit_hooks	4433701.27215208 ns/iter	4490505.116128559 ns/iter	0.99
E2E_Compiler_pulumi	3475942.2326733153 ns/iter	3540112.4467004826 ns/iter	0.98
E2E_Compiler_semantic_release	1275976.6775960051 ns/iter	1296554.6857672248 ns/iter	0.98
E2E_Compiler_stale	1292430.2394106805 ns/iter	1315041.4849058436 ns/iter	0.98
E2E_Compiler_stylecop	5469196.181104597 ns/iter	5549305.920001643 ns/iter	0.99
E2E_Compiler_tmuxinator	1599285.7608201252 ns/iter	1630878.3773147885 ns/iter	0.98
E2E_Compiler_ui5	41242051.76471792 ns/iter	44248938.62500312 ns/iter	0.93
E2E_Compiler_ui5_manifest	268604457.6665457 ns/iter	287272518.5000036 ns/iter	0.94
E2E_Compiler_unreal_engine_uproject	3890822.44692725 ns/iter	3982829.591954758 ns/iter	0.98
E2E_Compiler_users_array	701728.2532661057 ns/iter	717165.8239508198 ns/iter	0.98
E2E_Compiler_vercel	11376968.419353357 ns/iter	11641465.800001545 ns/iter	0.98
E2E_Compiler_yamllint	287094.00449708605 ns/iter	296710.870537623 ns/iter	0.97
E2E_Evaluator_adaptivecard	26568.49702045391 ns/iter	26993.072785047058 ns/iter	0.98
E2E_Evaluator_ansible_meta	294756.63219833426 ns/iter	293469.8364248976 ns/iter	1.00
E2E_Evaluator_aws_cdk	63284.858262065165 ns/iter	63233.58193314813 ns/iter	1.00
E2E_Evaluator_babelrc	119989.34870218893 ns/iter	121088.52967333216 ns/iter	0.99
E2E_Evaluator_cerebrum_criminal_case	1147379.5697475763 ns/iter	1174368.9008262889 ns/iter	0.98
E2E_Evaluator_clang_format	108008.06303551953 ns/iter	104741.902435414 ns/iter	1.03
E2E_Evaluator_cmake_presets	4977617.182481003 ns/iter	5602523.923729585 ns/iter	0.89
E2E_Evaluator_code_climate	235665.92056553965 ns/iter	233788.46153847082 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Evaluator_cql2	235418.70662666165 ns/iter	233037.78731967343 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Evaluator_cspell	626042.4692588786 ns/iter	646392.3941337304 ns/iter	0.97
E2E_Evaluator_cypress	196242.40922981114 ns/iter	193700.9609879402 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Evaluator_deno	360119.25578998035 ns/iter	365086.06154649064 ns/iter	0.99
E2E_Evaluator_dependabot	396910.32654227497 ns/iter	394346.60136285133 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Evaluator_draft_04	8212094.453332004 ns/iter	9553901.619720422 ns/iter	0.86
E2E_Evaluator_fabric_mod	791454.5248867321 ns/iter	791117.815699483 ns/iter	1.00
E2E_Evaluator_geojson	12984232.925924111 ns/iter	13631847.352942213 ns/iter	0.95
E2E_Evaluator_gitpod_configuration	281076.9413616434 ns/iter	282595.2105477101 ns/iter	0.99
E2E_Evaluator_helm_chart_lock	359606.2763563866 ns/iter	360932.1732283373 ns/iter	1.00
E2E_Evaluator_importmap	48231.34812673241 ns/iter	50210.25306928474 ns/iter	0.96
E2E_Evaluator_jasmine	126532.39567950004 ns/iter	126260.51238902929 ns/iter	1.00
E2E_Evaluator_jshintrc	1115952.7958859974 ns/iter	1121932.6624203117 ns/iter	0.99
E2E_Evaluator_jsconfig	457846.553664985 ns/iter	463742.42514958495 ns/iter	0.99
E2E_Evaluator_krakend	222139.71201014833 ns/iter	223413.22952379123 ns/iter	0.99
E2E_Evaluator_lazygit	155111.2543878645 ns/iter	153968.54853173764 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Evaluator_lerna	169710.81842489168 ns/iter	173802.8316125808 ns/iter	0.98
E2E_Evaluator_nest_cli	215175.48124433157 ns/iter	212531.565729876 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Evaluator_omc	24417.847442930048 ns/iter	24324.57632998262 ns/iter	1.00
E2E_Evaluator_omnisharp	600502.1705226956 ns/iter	596614.3707482951 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Evaluator_openapi	15762657.837216847 ns/iter	19095614.32432531 ns/iter	0.83
E2E_Evaluator_pre_commit_hooks	543993.7052470628 ns/iter	550478.5069766766 ns/iter	0.99
E2E_Evaluator_pulumi	785405.9351233388 ns/iter	791049.8629215591 ns/iter	0.99
E2E_Evaluator_semantic_release	108668.95127544474 ns/iter	110121.26180458188 ns/iter	0.99
E2E_Evaluator_stale	178037.42853455106 ns/iter	179056.39402593428 ns/iter	0.99
E2E_Evaluator_stylecop	319615.26081019343 ns/iter	322240.39653557097 ns/iter	0.99
E2E_Evaluator_tmuxinator	111398.92087358283 ns/iter	112866.40959820966 ns/iter	0.99
E2E_Evaluator_ui5	628428.8909575564 ns/iter	632317.8249098441 ns/iter	0.99
E2E_Evaluator_ui5_manifest	3103209.6888884553 ns/iter	3332027.684685166 ns/iter	0.93
E2E_Evaluator_unreal_engine_uproject	503275.7343976758 ns/iter	503337.05632774293 ns/iter	1.00
E2E_Evaluator_users_array	686977.1245098544 ns/iter	678570.6327130878 ns/iter	1.01
E2E_Evaluator_vercel	356860.9955067685 ns/iter	356432.67617110733 ns/iter	1.00
E2E_Evaluator_yamllint	13439.837119414431 ns/iter	13237.096745008277 ns/iter	1.02
Schema_Format_ISO_Language_To_JSON	101991558.00007378 ns/iter	107828502.8333615 ns/iter	0.95
Schema_Bundle_Meta_2020_12	1458032.618557274 ns/iter	1483029.345987514 ns/iter	0.98
Schema_Frame_WoT_References	4702404.651008643 ns/iter	4796616.061644397 ns/iter	0.98
Schema_Frame_OMC_References	20966120.000001397 ns/iter	22967761.000002913 ns/iter	0.91
Schema_Frame_OMC_Locations	19724148.833334867 ns/iter	21449625.500000525 ns/iter	0.92
Schema_Frame_ISO_Language_Locations	93712603.57141052 ns/iter	100197188.71428397 ns/iter	0.94
Schema_Frame_ISO_Language_Root	460.20882236666154 ns/iter	430.2199634052037 ns/iter	1.07
Schema_Frame_KrakenD_References	37828794.78945975 ns/iter	40434182.11765183 ns/iter	0.94
Schema_Frame_KrakenD_Reachable	445546513.99994326 ns/iter	461121283.99988705 ns/iter	0.97
Schema_Frame_ISO_Language_Locations_To_JSON	198522020.6665872 ns/iter	202845707.00005135 ns/iter	0.98
Schema_Frame_Many_Resources_References	347777329.9998717 ns/iter	356462469.500002 ns/iter	0.98
Schema_Frame_Deeply_Nested_References	11124260.111111134 ns/iter	11835933.81355715 ns/iter	0.94
Schema_Tracker_ISO_Language	5203843.69117972 ns/iter	5257110.837399198 ns/iter	0.99
Schema_Tracker_ISO_Language_To_JSON	19082415.540541094 ns/iter	19476388.54053858 ns/iter	0.98

This comment was automatically generated by workflow using github-action-benchmark.

[github-actions]

JavaScript (linux/gcc)

Details

Benchmark suite	Current: d6f2e44	Previous: e8b95e6	Ratio
E2E_Evaluator_adaptivecard	120039 ns	121791 ns	0.99
E2E_Evaluator_ansible-meta	515224 ns	538733 ns	0.96
E2E_Evaluator_aws-cdk	145694 ns	158006 ns	0.92
E2E_Evaluator_babelrc	339146 ns	340458 ns	1.00
E2E_Evaluator_cerebrum-criminal-case	2460843 ns	2505331 ns	0.98
E2E_Evaluator_clang-format	243744 ns	264295 ns	0.92
E2E_Evaluator_cmake-presets	18019188 ns	19535349 ns	0.92
E2E_Evaluator_code-climate	528517 ns	525129 ns	1.01
E2E_Evaluator_cql2	1328023 ns	1332071 ns	1.00
E2E_Evaluator_cspell	1479057 ns	1541179 ns	0.96
E2E_Evaluator_cypress	763967 ns	805815 ns	0.95
E2E_Evaluator_deno	1048767 ns	1087252 ns	0.96
E2E_Evaluator_dependabot	1114084 ns	1137523 ns	0.98
E2E_Evaluator_draft-04	21324634 ns	23899190 ns	0.89
E2E_Evaluator_fabric-mod	2309722 ns	2405831 ns	0.96
E2E_Evaluator_geojson	23327424 ns	25504238 ns	0.91
E2E_Evaluator_gitpod-configuration	709464 ns	720945 ns	0.98
E2E_Evaluator_helm-chart-lock	993194 ns	1047110 ns	0.95
E2E_Evaluator_importmap	269272 ns	264390 ns	1.02
E2E_Evaluator_jasmine	289996 ns	302776 ns	0.96
E2E_Evaluator_jsconfig	1194575 ns	1243325 ns	0.96
E2E_Evaluator_jshintrc	2721061 ns	2870084 ns	0.95
E2E_Evaluator_krakend	655255 ns	670105 ns	0.98
E2E_Evaluator_lazygit	495321 ns	514754 ns	0.96
E2E_Evaluator_lerna	450558 ns	483947 ns	0.93
E2E_Evaluator_nest-cli	591589 ns	610897 ns	0.97
E2E_Evaluator_omc	119233 ns	120438 ns	0.99
E2E_Evaluator_omnisharp	1400385 ns	1439838 ns	0.97
E2E_Evaluator_openapi	43534695 ns	47267543 ns	0.92
E2E_Evaluator_pre-commit-hooks	1965402 ns	2009492 ns	0.98
E2E_Evaluator_pulumi	1852838 ns	1941975 ns	0.95
E2E_Evaluator_semantic-release	252566 ns	254677 ns	0.99
E2E_Evaluator_stale	396830 ns	408087 ns	0.97
E2E_Evaluator_stylecop	1192104 ns	1209889 ns	0.99
E2E_Evaluator_tmuxinator	228528 ns	228123 ns	1.00
E2E_Evaluator_ui5	2213042 ns	2248577 ns	0.98
E2E_Evaluator_ui5-manifest	10235168 ns	11938973 ns	0.86
E2E_Evaluator_unreal-engine-uproject	1492009 ns	1547765 ns	0.96
E2E_Evaluator_users-array	2966530 ns	3000101 ns	0.99
E2E_Evaluator_vercel	958067 ns	995125 ns	0.96
E2E_Evaluator_yamllint	25387 ns	26017 ns	0.98

This comment was automatically generated by workflow using github-action-benchmark.

[augmentcode]

🤖 Augment PR Summary

Summary: This PR extends canonicalization of unevaluatedProperties.
It recognizes schemas whose sole in-place branch is allOf: [{ $ref: ... }].
The referenced target is resolved through SchemaFrame to honor effective base URIs.
Known target properties names are copied to the local schema as true schemas.
The original unevaluatedProperties keyword is then renamed to additionalProperties.
The referenced branch itself remains unchanged, preserving its validation constraints.
The rule rejects targets with further references, in-place applicators, or property-evaluating keywords.
It also limits the optimization to modern JSON Schema applicator vocabularies.
New 2019-09 and 2020-12 canonicalizer tests cover the successful transformation.
Additional negative tests cover anyOf, additionalProperties, patterns, conditionals, and uncovered required names.
The canonicalizer build list and rule registration now include the new transform.
The aim is to eliminate a common real-world unevaluatedProperties pattern that previously survived canonicalization.

_{🤖 Was this summary useful? React with 👍 or 👎}

[augmentcode]

Review completed. No suggestions at this time.

Comment augment review to trigger a new review at any time.

[augmentcode]

Review completed. 1 suggestion posted.

Comment augment review to trigger a new review at any time.

[augmentcode]

src/canonicalizer/rules/unevaluated_properties_to_additional_properties_single_ref.h:132: This only defers the rewrite: required_properties_in_properties subsequently adds the uncovered name to the target's properties, the canonicalizer restarts, and this rule then succeeds and copies it locally. For a target requiring extra but initially defining only shared, the resulting additionalProperties accepts extra, while the original unevaluatedProperties: false rejects it because required does not evaluate that property.

Severity: high

_{🤖 Was this useful? React with 👍 or 👎, or 🚀 if it prevented an incident/outage.}

[cubic-dev-ai]

2 issues found across 5 files

Prompt for AI agents (unresolved issues)

Check if these issues are valid — if so, understand the root cause of each and fix them. If appropriate, use sub-agents to investigate and fix each issue separately.


<file name="test/canonicalizer/canonicalizer_2019_09_test.cc">

<violation number="1" location="test/canonicalizer/canonicalizer_2019_09_test.cc:796">
P2: These tests assert only that the canonicalized output matches the expected structure and is a valid schema; they never check that the rewrite preserves runtime evaluation behavior. Since this rewrite merges referenced property names into `properties` and converts `unevaluatedProperties` to `additionalProperties` (and the PR claims no behavior change), an evaluator-level equivalence test comparing the original and canonicalized schema against a set of object instances would guard against semantic regressions that the structural assertion cannot catch.</violation>
</file>

<file name="src/canonicalizer/rules/unevaluated_properties_to_additional_properties_single_ref.h">

<violation number="1" location="src/canonicalizer/rules/unevaluated_properties_to_additional_properties_single_ref.h:143">
P1: When a referenced schema's `required` name is added to `properties` by a later canonicalization rule, this loop copies that synthesized name into the enclosing `properties`. The subsequent `additionalProperties` rewrite then accepts a property that the original `unevaluatedProperties: false` rejects; preserve the uncovered-required guard across canonicalization passes.</violation>
</file>

<sub>Reply with feedback, questions, or to request a fix.

Re-trigger cubic</sub>

[cubic-dev-ai]

P1: When a referenced schema's required name is added to properties by a later canonicalization rule, this loop copies that synthesized name into the enclosing properties. The subsequent additionalProperties rewrite then accepts a property that the original unevaluatedProperties: false rejects; preserve the uncovered-required guard across canonicalization passes.

Prompt for AI agents

Check if this issue is valid — if so, understand the root cause and fix it. At src/canonicalizer/rules/unevaluated_properties_to_additional_properties_single_ref.h, line 143:

<comment>When a referenced schema's `required` name is added to `properties` by a later canonicalization rule, this loop copies that synthesized name into the enclosing `properties`. The subsequent `additionalProperties` rewrite then accepts a property that the original `unevaluatedProperties: false` rejects; preserve the uncovered-required guard across canonicalization passes.</comment>

<file context>
@@ -0,0 +1,173 @@
+        if (properties && properties->defines(entry.first)) {
+          continue;
+        }
+        this->properties_.emplace_back(entry.first);
+      }
+    }
</file context>

[cubic-dev-ai]

P2: These tests assert only that the canonicalized output matches the expected structure and is a valid schema; they never check that the rewrite preserves runtime evaluation behavior. Since this rewrite merges referenced property names into properties and converts unevaluatedProperties to additionalProperties (and the PR claims no behavior change), an evaluator-level equivalence test comparing the original and canonicalized schema against a set of object instances would guard against semantic regressions that the structural assertion cannot catch.

Prompt for AI agents

Check if this issue is valid — if so, understand the root cause and fix it. At test/canonicalizer/canonicalizer_2019_09_test.cc, line 796:

<comment>These tests assert only that the canonicalized output matches the expected structure and is a valid schema; they never check that the rewrite preserves runtime evaluation behavior. Since this rewrite merges referenced property names into `properties` and converts `unevaluatedProperties` to `additionalProperties` (and the PR claims no behavior change), an evaluator-level equivalence test comparing the original and canonicalized schema against a set of object instances would guard against semantic regressions that the structural assertion cannot catch.</comment>

<file context>
@@ -746,6 +746,378 @@ TEST(items_implicit_1) {
+    }
+  })JSON");
+
+  CANONICALIZE_AND_VALIDATE(document, expected, compiled_metaschema());
+}
+
</file context>