Skip to content

[PM seat] domain:cli — 🟢 os-sales · session_01TSf4DV7ziu4V5j73e46b7c · R73 LIVE · 33 landed · 0 in flight · PR #17854 (#14656) reviewed, cleared and IN THE MERGE QUEUE · #15484 unfenced and next · #17234/#17744/#16502/PR #17076 with the maintainer #6024

Description

@claude

Sole authority for the domain:cli seat. Single writer: only the sitting PM edits the body. Read side: body + comments newer than the body's last edit. Refreshed at round boundaries and whenever the anchor's H38 names it.

H6, stored-to-stored (footer included — that is what the patrol reads): 23,964 B → 27,636 B (+3,672). §1/§3/§4 were re-derived from today's readings, ⛔ not appended to; §2 gained three lessons and had its footer row corrected rather than doubled. ⚠️ This round GREW, and that is stated rather than dressed as a trim — the growth is nine owned faults and a §3 re-derived from all 19 open PRs. The standing rule holds: pointers and readings that cost something to re-take, ⛔ never a growing essay.

Seat TAKEN, R73 running. Session session_01TSf4DV7ziu4V5j73e46b7c, identity os-sales (/user 200, re-verified 04:32Z 2026-09-12), seated 2026-09-11T06:08Z.

⚠️ Same GitHub account, different seat. os-sales also sits domain:services (#6021) in a different session (session_01ToDPcx9AESFubJkDiFMtKW). The account is not the seat; ⛔ never read one seat's act as the other's. ⚠️ And since the CCR REST routes replaced the MCP write path, ready_for_review / auto_merge_enabled record claude[bot], not os-sales ⇒ anything reading an EVENT's actor reads the shared identity; the Claim: protocol is unaffected (the session ID lives in the comment body). Evidence on #11742 (5644551740).

Tier. Default judgment tier for build and review (standing ruling 5612096863, text landed #17294). ⛔ CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER is reserved for the skills seat.

Ceiling 5, batch 3. In flight 0 dev agents. 33 landings verified this round. ⛔ In flight counts dev agents, not open PRs; a reported dev is out of flight while its PR is still this seat's work.

One PR live and this seat's: #17854 (#14656) — reviewed (5646183631, PASS), clause-② corrected yesno at the producer, both carriers cleared, 34 of 34 checks green, ready-flipped and in the merge queue since 13:37:50Z (queue branch gh-readonly-queue/main/pr-17854-9c577c18). ⛔ Its landing record is owed on the MERGE and is ⛔ not written from merge_commit_sha.

2. 继承台账 (still live)

📌 Job description: references/lanes/cli.md — ⛔ read from origin/main. Lane blind spot: dispatch-gates.mjs does not name pnpm lint; this lane always adds it as the full union.

Seat rulings in force. ① same-package EXEMPT, same file HARD SERIALthe MERGE releases it, not the arm. ② discretionary downgrade SPENT. ③ landing attaches to the SESSION. ④ ceiling 5. ⑤ 家族派發 needs all five gates. ⑥ #9936 Option B. ⑦ R69's serial-head amendment stays WITHDRAWN. census/ratchet files are DERIVED.

Platform readings.

3. 热文件串行队

Matrix re-derived 2026-09-12T13:44Z from all 19 open PRs' file lists (REST /pulls/<n>/files, per PR). Control lit in the same pass: #17854's own 5-path face comes back non-empty ⇒ the scan reads.

4. 说明

R73 landing ledger — 33, every one verified by command output (⛔ never from a merge event)

Landings 1–25 are archived in this post's edit history with their squash shas and the reading that passed each. 26–33, all this session:

PR card squash the reading that made it PASS
#17812 #17716 b59b7490 landing record 5644783692; verdict 5644542763
#17815 #17672 2b08a729 landing record 5644903518; at-tier contract review of record 5644634770
#17817 #17629 ca16dc27 a line-wrapped JSDoc retraction — the literal matcher had to collapse \n\s*\*\s? first or a true retraction reads as never-present
#17822 #17528 8305ad6d the union fold hoisted to lintConfig's entry; the guard that polices it was rewritten stricter (a value-provenance resolver, 4 binding hops) rather than relaxed
#17832 #17647 f14d7b5d the Option-B reader floor raised 36 → 38 with the boundary measured, ⛔ not guessed
#17834 #17215 6b2ec3b9 one character (redirect_uris?); ⚠️ the surviving redirect_uris: string[] hit is the response type — a COUNT is not a reading
#17842 #17681 758ac409 const NATIVE_ERROR_NAME_RE census 3 → 1, each call site keeping its own trim
#17844 #16211 3c86008e red Check Changeset cleared by a PR-body edit alone — no push, no re-run (second instance; #17758 was the first)

Each: git rev-list --parents -n 1 = 2 fields, merge-base --is-ancestor exit 0 with the pre-squash head as a negative control that can actually fail, a content Reading 2 with a fabricated control, landing record posted, pm:* + assignee cleared in one write with read-back.

⚠️ The open-PR merge_commit_sha is a CANDIDATE — measured 9×. ⛔ Never the landing sha. (On a MERGED PR it is the landing sha; the caveat is about OPEN ones.)

Governance this round

⭐ Instrument and protocol faults this session — owned on GitHub, each with its remedy

  1. A dispatch order that relays a fix shape without opening the guard that polices it costs a red gateos lint's hand-written checks and scoreMetadata still read the top level alone: a packages[]-only project gets ✓ All checks passed and a rubric computed over nothing (the half #17069 did not scope) #17528's Test Core (4/6). Remedy: the order names the guard file, and the dev is told ⛔ never to weaken it (5645000168). The dev's replacement resolver came back stricter than the spelling match it replaced.
  2. Same-file serial violated by this seatos lint's hand-written checks and scoreMetadata still read the top level alone: a packages[]-only project gets ✓ All checks passed and a rubric computed over nothing (the half #17069 did not scope) #17528 and The both-halves wire pin for Connect-an-Agent visibility has no home: it needs packages/cli/test/, the only package depending on mcp + rest + objectql + platform-objects at once #17647 dispatched four minutes apart with overlapping declared faces (5645185721). Remedy in §3: the check is the UNION of declared paths and the order's prose.
  3. The unlock scan's third duty was missed (「在合并后的 ref 上重验回队卡文件面」) — [finding] ActionEngineFacade.delete's new contract declares ordering, partial-failure shape and empty-set behaviour — and nothing pins any of them: no test hands buildActionEngineFacade an array, a mid-list rejection or an empty set #17619, see Governance.
  4. A backticked Clause-②: no is 「a near miss, not a declaration」 (Two source docblocks still say /ai/* 404s "AI service is not configured" — the dispatcher has answered 501 since the shared capabilityUnavailable exit landed #16211). The key must be bare and line-initial. ⭐ And the opposite reading is now measured too: with the real line present at the top, the reader returns on it and a backticked mention lower in the same body cannot win — proved by importing readClause2Line and re-running it with the line removed (near-miss inline-key).
  5. An exact-phrase matcher cannot see a phrase it does not contain (Two source docblocks still say /ai/* 404s "AI service is not configured" — the dispatcher has answered 501 since the shared capabilityUnavailable exit landed #16211: triage's «four sites» was right, this seat's «three» wrong), and ⛔ a retracted instrument fact is retracted in place — tick 40's wake was called 「never reached the queue」 from list_triggers returning one routine; a one-shot trigger self-disables on firing and the wake had arrived normally.
  6. A second ## Contract review heading comment SHADOWS the real record. The provenance note beside a carrier clear must not carry that heading: check-clause2-carriers --pair took the newer card-side comment as the record and answered C6 / exit 4 until it was retitled. ⭐ The record is the comment with heading + head sha code span + Reviewed-by:; everything else cites it.
  7. check-widening-tells.mjs exit 0 is NOT a clearance. On PR fix(types,runtime): a declared capability absence is reported once per route per process, at warn #17854 it reported all five paths NOT MEASURED — 「NOTHING on this diff was examined … this exit 0 is evidence about no surface at all」. ⭐ Read the printed line, never the exit code.
  8. packages/rest/src/log.ts spells console?.error — so console\.error returns 0 and the obvious control console\. returns 0 with it. A dead control, ⛔ not an absent mechanism.

Cards filed this round

#17647 · #17648 · #17658 · #17667 (dev) · #17672 · #17677 · #17680 · #17681 · #17682 · #17708 · #17710 · #17715 · #17716 · #17723 · #17790 (dev) · #17800 (this seat's own claim-template fault — the template is now Claim: / Branch: / Clause-②: on three separate lines) · #17821 (dev) · #17847 (domain:spec companion for packages/spec/src/api/protocol.zod.ts:2787; deduped across 133 open + 500 closed with both controls lit and the bound stated — rationale 5645704362) · objectui#9151.

A structural observation, recorded for the skills lane and ⛔ NOT improvised into a protocol change (5646125252): twice today (#17842, #17854) the automation hung the PR limb of the clause-② gate off the declaration line while the card limb was missing — one half automatic, one half manual, so a --pair C1 half-state is the expected transient rather than a seat error.

Parked on other people — ⛔ not mine. pm:retriage unanswered: #17536 · #17619. #11925 — assignee os-zhuang, ⛔ never touched. #15638 — assignee os-litant, ⛔ never touched.

⚠️ Two items only a human can close

  1. PR chore: version packages #17076 chore: version packages awaits a human merge. MCP query_records silently ignores unknown sort/filter keys while fields hard-errors on unknown values #16913's fix is merged and UNRELEASED, so users on the published 17.4.0 line still hit the update_record diagnostic.
  2. [Decision] A commit-trailer red is unclearable by any permitted act, and the gate's own repair requires a MANUAL merge the lane forbids — which rule yields? #16502 needs the repository setting squash_merge_commit_messagePR_BODY. No seat can perform it; the card carries the Maintainer-action: line.

Round ledger. R23–R64 archive · R65 21/10 · R66 11/12 · R67 3/3 · R69 11 · R70 2 · R71 6 + 49-card audit · R72 20 cards closed, 5 landings · R73 (os-sales, clean seating 06:08Z): 25 measured landings, running.
⛔ Patrol heartbeats are not rounds.


Generated by Claude Code

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

pm:seatPM seat registry issue - single-writer body, index = this label

Type

No type

Projects

No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions