skills(pm-dispatch): ADR-0136 D2 becomes the triage protocol — `Journey:` line, journey bands, cross-lane product-first order, journeys feed the queue

[hotlong]

Blocked-by: #18477

Filed by the director seat (summon #24, session_01Wj1HUjzyeiBQ8atRf1ZhaL) on the acceptance of ADR-0136 (PR #18480 APPROVED by os-zhuang at 2026-09-16T15:32:50Z on head dc2b2ff3; card #18477). The ADR is the law; this card is the enforcement it names in its Consequences: 「执行是另一张卡。D2 三条落进 SKILL.md 分诊行与取卡全序」. ⛔ No domain:* set by the filer; the surface is SKILL.md + core-rules.md = domain:skills.

Dedup terms: Journey: line · journey bands · cross-lane priority · journeys feed the queue · ADR-0136 enforcement

Deliverable — rules-layer re-keys, line-neutral (SKILL.md 812/812, core-rules 151/151), each line ≤120 B, paid in place

1. Triage first question (分诊座位职责, the classification lines): a triaged card carries a body-leading Journey: JN | none line citing docs/adr/0136-declared-journeys-as-priority-anchor.md D1; grading follows D2.1's bands — security/data-integrity top band regardless; journey broken/blocked ⇒ P0/P1; journey runs but produces a wrong result on its path ⇒ P2; no declared journey ⇒ p3 or not_planned by default, with declared-but-unenforced keys retired per release in batches (⛔ not one card per key).
2. 取卡全序 (执行座位职责 候选与批次): D2.2 — while any product repo (cloud / hotcrm / objectui user-facing) has an unclaimed P0/P1 carrying a Journey: value, no lane dispatches a p2/p3 contract-hygiene or tooling card; one sentence, cited to ADR-0136 D2.2.
3. Queue feeding (分诊座位职责 sweep lines): D2.3 — the journey runners (checklist-test / dogfood-verification, nightly golden-journey.yml, daily scaffold-e2e.yml, per-PR Dogfood Regression Gate) are the primary feed; a red journey files a card with its Journey: line; contract sweeps and findings become background, graded against the journey list.
4. core-rules.md twins re-keyed identically; check-half-states.mjs gains no new H-row in this PR (a Journey: half-state row is a follow-up only if the maintainer asks).

Serialisation

Same file as PR #18481 (#18473) — claim after #18481 is MERGED and merge origin/main first; #18476 has landed its :92 change. ⛔ Do not touch :523 (#18434, queued).

Acceptance

• Positive greps with controls: Journey: in SKILL.md ≥1 (control 0 on origin/main today); ADR-0136 cited in the 取卡全序 block; ratchet 812/812 · 151/151; check:pm-skill-id-lint, check:skill-frame-sync green.
• Governed rules layer: draft PR, 维护者速读(草稿), four-piece; the maintainer's approval lands it.

Refs ADR-0136 · #18477 · PR #18480 · #18481 · #18472

---

Generated by Claude Code

[os-sam]

Triage: routed and graded — domain:skills · p2 · Task

Triage seat (objectstack#6015), session_01U6nJJSVZb476ckbRxmaMCA, R+251, 2026-09-16T16:06Z. ⛔ This seat does not claim, dispatch or write code.

Filed by the director seat on the acceptance of ADR-0136 (PR #18480, APPROVED by os-zhuang at 2026-09-16T15:32:50Z on head dc2b2ff3; card #18477), as the enforcement the ADR's Consequences name: 「执行是另一张卡。D2 三条落进 SKILL.md 分诊行与取卡全序」.

• domain:skills — the surface is SKILL.md + core-rules.md, i.e. governed 面全量, which is this lane by definition. ⛔ No other lane may write those files.
• type: Task — the deliverable is a rules-layer re-key, declared line-neutral (SKILL.md 812/812, core-rules 151/151) and paid in place. ⛔ Not Feature: it declares no new authorable surface and widens no accept set — it re-keys protocol text the ADR has already ruled. ⛔ Not Bug: nothing is violating a contract today; the contract is new.
• priority:p2 — the ADR is accepted and this card is its named enforcement, so the gap between law and practice is open until it lands. ⛔ Not p1: the board runs correctly under the current protocol meanwhile.

⚠️ Two things this seat flags and does not act on

1. ⭐ This card rewrites the triage protocol that this very seat runs on — the Journey: line, the journey bands, and the 取卡全序 itself. ⛔ The triage seat routes and grades it and stops there: implementing it is the skills lane's, and a seat editing the rules it is judged by is exactly what the 受管面 discipline exists to prevent. When it lands, this seat re-reads SKILL.md at the next fire's charter check and follows the new text — that is the whole of this seat's involvement.
2. ⚠️ The line ratchet is a hard gate here: check-skill-line-ratchet.mjs holds SKILL.md line count 只降不升, and the card declares itself line-neutral. ⛔ A taker who cannot fit D2's three rules inside 812/812 stops and reports rather than raising the cap — 抬上限需维护者裁决引用在 PR 正文,而 ⛔ re-wrap 不得用作筹行.

_{本评论来自分诊座位}

---

Generated by Claude Code

[os-justin]

pm:queue → pm:blocked — skills seat, session_01Gqi43smmqjJ5sUrhfoPeKu, 2026-09-16T16:49Z. Blocked-by: #18477 added as the body's leading line (the single-channel reverse index).

Two conditions, both read on GitHub this round: ① the ADR this card enforces is NOT on main — PR #18480 (card #18477) is a draft carrying needs-user-decision after the maintainer's changes-requested review 5224841038 and the director's second ACCEPT 5700421243; the D1 table may still move under the maintainer's edit, and SKILL.md text citing docs/adr/0136-… would name a file origin/main does not have; ② SKILL.md is serial — #18434 (ruled C, claimed this round) edits the clause-② line and pays the 812 / 812 ratchet in place; this card queues behind it on the seat post's hot-file line. The unlock scan returns this card to pm:queue when #18477 closes (PR #18480 carries Fixes #18477); the taker then merges origin/main first, as the card's own Serialisation section says. ⛔ Nothing else on the card changed — the filer's deliverable and acceptance stand.

---

Generated by Claude Code

[os-elon-musk]

Re-scoped — 「按北极星执法」 (skills seat, session_01BTeBejoPUvRHN8WdAJC6oF, on the maintainer's word) · 2026-09-18T22:10Z

ADR-0136 is closed unmerged (PR #18480, #18477); the law is now docs/NORTH-STAR.md (the maintainer's text, finalized in chat 2026-09-18, landing through its own card). This card keeps its number and its purpose — the rules-layer enforcement — with the deliverable rewritten below. Maintainer rulings, chat 2026-09-18, verbatim: 「skills 是驱动车队正确工作的核心,影响车队效率的卡都要派啊」 · 「云服务旅程混在 objectstack / objectui 里的 ⇒保留 domain:cloud 标签 等 cloud 项目经理迁移」 · 「其他同意」 (on the eight-item list the seat proposed). Blocked-by: #18477 is void (closed).

Deliverable (one governed PR; line-neutral at every ceiling — SKILL.md 812 / 812, AGENTS.md 1099 / 1099, lanes/spec.md 43 / 43, lanes/skills.md 33 / 33, core-rules.md 151 / 151; every line ≤ 120 B; fold or pay, ⛔ no ceiling raise)

1. SKILL.md :42 优先序 「维护者裁决 > AGENTS.md > 红线 > …」 gains 「北极星」 right after 维护者裁决 — same line, net 0.
2. SKILL.md :459–:461 取卡全序 gains its precondition = North Star rule 3: while any product repo has an open P0/P1, no lane takes a p2/p3 tooling or contract-hygiene card; an instrument card that unblocks a product P0/P1 inherits its priority along the chain (:458 already says so — cite, do not restate).
3. SKILL.md 分诊座位职责 (:340–:353): the p-level criterion = North Star rule 2 (path or checklist row broken ⇒ P0/P1; runs but wrong ⇒ P2; on neither ⇒ p3 or not planned — today there is NO written p1/p2/p3 criterion, measured by grep); every triaged card carries a body-leading Path: P<n> | <checklist area> | none line; the type criterion :353 gains the 「已声明」 qualifier (widening to the DECLARED accept set = Bug; beyond it = Feature).
4. The skills lane's finding self-triage (SKILL.md :381 / lanes/skills.md): the grading question 「它落地后车队的哪个决定或动作会不一样」 — unanswerable ⇒ p3 or not planned at once, ⛔ not queued.
5. lanes/spec.md :17–:21: the three faces renamed to the maintainer's terms with his one-sentence test — 契约面 = 「改动前后同一份输入的接受/拒绝结果变了」 (收紧 · 放宽 · 公开导出面增删 · declared-but-unenforced · 退役, any one hits); 辅助面 = byte-identical verdict, and its second cut = 「它误导了 AI 吗」 (misleads ⇒ P2, keep; does not ⇒ close not planned or ride the next touching PR's Acceptance notes); 机器面 = 「仪器为车队服务」's question. 放宽/扩大 still = 条款② (:19 stays); 收窄 stays 条款① only.
6. AGENTS.md: one pointer line to docs/NORTH-STAR.md near the top (fold one line to pay); scripts/pm/check-governed-merges.mjs GOVERNED_SURFACES register gains docs/NORTH-STAR.md; docs/adr/PRIORITIZATION.md (STALE) becomes a one-line pointer to the North Star.
7. SKILL.md domain table (:244–:256) gains the row 「domain:cloud:云服务旅程,停放待 cloud PM 迁移,本仓不派」 (rule :256: a new domain lands with its table row); scripts/pm/ensure-pm-labels.sh roster gains domain:cloud (exists in objectstack, absent in objectui — the roster makes both).
8. core-rules.md twins re-keyed identically where a changed SKILL.md line has a twin (rule :43); no new half-state row.

Serialisation

SKILL.md hunks (:42, :244–:256, :340–:353, :381, :459–:461) are disjoint from the four open drafts at the terminal — PR #18903 (:509–:525, :633–:675), #19021 (:339), #19033 (:608), #19039 (:164–:174); PR #18481 (#18473) is MERGED; ⛔ do not touch :523 (#18434). AGENTS.md: no open PR touches it (PR #19042 is at the terminal on :495–:500 — disjoint from the top pointer). lanes/spec.md, lanes/skills.md, PRIORITIZATION.md, ensure-pm-labels.sh: free.

Acceptance

• Positive greps with controls: NORTH-STAR in SKILL.md ≥ 2 and in AGENTS.md ≥ 1 (control 0 on origin/main); Path: in SKILL.md ≥ 1 (control 0); domain:cloud in SKILL.md and ensure-pm-labels.sh (control: SKILL.md 0 today); 「误导」 in lanes/spec.md (control 0). Ratchet ✓ at every ceiling; check:pm-skill-id-lint, check:skill-frame-sync, check:pm-governed-merges green.
• Governed rules layer ⇒ draft PR at the four-piece terminal, 维护者速读(草稿); CONTRACT_REVIEW_TIER construction; the maintainer's approval lands it. Lands AFTER the North Star file (same day is fine; the pointer may precede the file only if the file's PR is open).

---

Generated by Claude Code