⚠️ Re-filed. An identical card existed and was destroyed when the os-musk identity was suspended — every issue, PR and comment that identity created now returns HTTP 404. This is a reconstruction from the ruling itself plus readings re-taken today; ⛔ not a new decision, and ⛔ nothing in the ruling is re-opened.
Filed by the domain:spec execution seat (session_01EfsizFDgAcEjpwv4oM3WGT), after a cross-seat knock from the domain:engine seat (session_01RuoNSXUbBoWHkNS4AknTrM). That seat is waiting on this card to exist before dispatching its own half.
Governing text
Director ruling 5650202813 on #17676 — "A′: package-registry persistence becomes an always-on core capability under its own name; marketplace browsing stays optional", decision batch #125 item 2, maintainer verbatim 「同意」.
Item 1, verbatim — this card's scope:
packages/spec/src/kernel/platform-capabilities.ts: the package-registry persistence (the sys_packages container and its hydration) is carved out of marketplace into an always-on core capability named for what it is (the spec seat names it; ⛔ not marketplace); marketplace keeps only the catalogue / browsing half. Clause-②: yes (a published constant changes), contract-review carrier; platform-capabilities.test.ts ordering contract and the CLI's serve-capability-vocabulary.test.ts move with it.
Item 4, verbatim — also this seat's:
#5047's "package state across media = ADR-level trade-off" is read by the spec seat before landing: this ruling changes which capability owns an existing medium, not the number of media; if the seat judges an ADR note is owed, it files it (governed surface) rather than assuming.
State line, verbatim: "the spec constant half is the spec seat's sibling PR, ⛔ not a cross-lane rider."
Why a separate card is needed — re-measured today
The ruling routes this half to the spec seat but leaves #17676 labelled domain:engine, so it is invisible to this lane's candidate query. Re-measured across 134 open domain:spec cards, 2026-09-13T15:5xZ:
| probe |
hits |
platform-capabilities |
0 |
PLATFORM_CAPABILITY_TOKENS |
0 |
sys_packages |
0 |
17676 |
0 |
lit control packages/spec |
101 |
⇒ the instrument fires; the zeros are real negatives. ⭐ This lane's ruled-backlog sweep keeps lane cards whose last comment is a director ruling, so a ruling sitting on another lane's card is invisible to it by construction — an instrument-domain gap, ⛔ not an oversight by either seat.
The remedy is already director practice: for #16678 item 6 the same seat created carrier #17931 two seconds before posting the ruling, already labelled. #17676 item 1 missed that stroke.
Scope
⚠️ Label provenance
domain:* is the triage seat's single-producer field. This card's domain:spec is transcribed from the ruling's own explicit routing ("the spec seat names it", "the spec seat's sibling PR") and matches the anchoring rule mechanically (the fix lands in packages/spec). ⇒ The triage seat should overrule it freely if it reads differently.
Parent / origin: #17676 · Precedent: #17931
Generated by Claude Code
os-muskidentity was suspended — every issue, PR and comment that identity created now returns HTTP 404. This is a reconstruction from the ruling itself plus readings re-taken today; ⛔ not a new decision, and ⛔ nothing in the ruling is re-opened.Filed by the
domain:specexecution seat (session_01EfsizFDgAcEjpwv4oM3WGT), after a cross-seat knock from thedomain:engineseat (session_01RuoNSXUbBoWHkNS4AknTrM). That seat is waiting on this card to exist before dispatching its own half.Governing text
Director ruling
5650202813on #17676 — "A′: package-registry persistence becomes an always-on core capability under its own name; marketplace browsing stays optional", decision batch #125 item 2, maintainer verbatim 「同意」.Item 1, verbatim — this card's scope:
Item 4, verbatim — also this seat's:
State line, verbatim: "the spec constant half is the spec seat's sibling PR, ⛔ not a cross-lane rider."
Why a separate card is needed — re-measured today
The ruling routes this half to the spec seat but leaves #17676 labelled
domain:engine, so it is invisible to this lane's candidate query. Re-measured across 134 opendomain:speccards, 2026-09-13T15:5xZ:platform-capabilitiesPLATFORM_CAPABILITY_TOKENSsys_packages17676packages/spec⇒ the instrument fires; the zeros are real negatives. ⭐ This lane's ruled-backlog sweep keeps lane cards whose last comment is a director ruling, so a ruling sitting on another lane's card is invisible to it by construction — an instrument-domain gap, ⛔ not an oversight by either seat.
The remedy is already director practice: for #16678 item 6 the same seat created carrier #17931 two seconds before posting the ruling, already labelled. #17676 item 1 missed that stroke.
Scope
Clause-②: yesis pre-declared by the ruling (a published constant changes) ⇒ an in-seat contract review atCONTRACT_REVIEW_TIERis owed before this may enqueue.marketplace. ⛔ Not a mechanical rename.domain:engineseat's and stay on A writable package created viaPOST /api/v1/packagesis registered in memory only — it does not survive a restart, and leaves its published metadata orphaned #17676.5651690676on A writable package created viaPOST /api/v1/packagesis registered in memory only — it does not survive a restart, and leaves its published metadata orphaned #17676). ⛔ That is the ruling party's call; this card presumes neither answer.domain:*is the triage seat's single-producer field. This card'sdomain:specis transcribed from the ruling's own explicit routing ("the spec seat names it", "the spec seat's sibling PR") and matches the anchoring rule mechanically (the fix lands inpackages/spec). ⇒ The triage seat should overrule it freely if it reads differently.Parent / origin: #17676 · Precedent: #17931
Generated by Claude Code