Repository navigation
Enterprise clustering and HA claims on the deploy pages exceed what the objectos-ee kit ships (Redis cluster driver, OS_CLUSTER_REPLICAS, "high availability") #443
Description
repo:cloud#1 · os-bob · session_012dn2AdARJtc4RgABPH7PHk
Filing gate: ① a user-visible misleading statement with a named location, found by the docs#350 dev (os-dev-report on #350, out_of_scope_findings class a and class b), measured against objectstack-ai/cloud main 9e71fd6a.
Reader: the repo:cloud lane (it carries Enterprise docs under the maintainer's 「cloud 相关的任务，转 cloud 车道处理」).
Dedupe (this repository, open and closed): cluster driver Redis → 1 hit (#350, the source); high availability HA → 1 hit (#350).
维护者速读
文档站有两处对企业版的承诺超出了安装包实际能做的:部署页叫运维开启 Redis 集群驱动并设置副本数,但企业版安装包现在根本没有接集群驱动,副本数设成大于 1 会直接拒绝启动;另外两页写了「集群与高可用」,而 cloud 的功能目录明确写着「不得承诺 HA」。客户照文档做会启动失败,或者被承诺了没有的能力。
Where
content/docs/deploy/docker.mdx§ "Multi-node on Enterprise" (/docs/deploy/docker#multi-node-on-enterprise): tells Enterprise operators to turn on the Redis cluster driver and setOS_CLUSTER_REPLICAS. The EE kit's README (cloudapps/objectos-ee/deploy/README.md:107-137) says no cluster driver is wired today andOS_CLUSTER_REPLICASabove 1 refuses the boot.content/docs/deploy/index.mdx(the editions table: "clustering and high availability") andcontent/docs/editions/license.mdx("Clustering / HA"): clouddocs/design/ee-feature-catalog.md:42says "Do NOT promise HA included".
Expected
- The pages state what the kit does today (single node; multi-node as the catalog allows it, with the boot refusal above 1 replica until a driver ships) and promise nothing the catalog forbids. English only; locale siblings per AGENTS.md (a reversed capability assertion deletes them in the same PR).
- Every claim cites the cloud path it rests on in the PR body.
Priority: p1 (a documented operator step that refuses to boot; an external promise the catalog forbids).
Activity
objectstack-fleet commentedon Nov 7, 2026
repo:cloud#1 · os-bob · session_012dn2AdARJtc4RgABPH7PHk
Claim · 2026-11-07T17:50Z
Claim: PM loop round R49
Session:
session_012dn2AdARJtc4RgABPH7PHkAccount:
os-bobBranch:
claude/issue-443-ee-cluster-ha-claimsWorktree:
/home/user/w12/docs-issue-443Domain:
domain:docs(carried by therepo:cloudlane)Seat:
repo:cloud#1File surface:
content/docs/deploy/docker.mdx(§ Multi-node on Enterprise),content/docs/deploy/index.mdx(editions table),content/docs/editions/license.mdx(Clustering / HA), and the locale siblings of any page whose capability assertion is reversed (deleted, per AGENTS.md). Stop on breach.Container & model:
S,mode:subagent,model: TIER_DEFAULT,effort: mediumClause-②: no
Metadata-protocol: none
Responsibility: the statements are this site's; the facts are cloud's (
apps/objectos-ee/deploy/README.md:107-137,docs/design/ee-feature-catalog.md:42on cloudmain).Thread-read: none
Premise: holds (measured by the docs#350 dev against cloud
main9e71fd6a).Serial constraints cleared: docs PR #442 (this seat) adds
deploy/licensing.mdxanddeploy/multi-organization.mdxand editsdeploy/meta.json— no file overlap with this surface.objectstack-fleet commentedon Nov 7, 2026
repo:cloud#1 · os-bob · session_012dn2AdARJtc4RgABPH7PHk
os-dev-report
{"issue":443,"status":"done","branch":"claude/issue-443-ee-cluster-ha-claims","pr":"https://github.com/objectstack-ai/docs.objectos.ai/pull/444","session":"session_012dn2AdARJtc4RgABPH7PHk","premise_still_valid":true,"summary":"Rewrote docs.objectos.ai deploy/docker.mdx 'Multi-node on Enterprise' to state single node today, OS_CLUSTER_REPLICAS>1 refuses boot, no HA promise, multi-node by license contract; reworded the editions-table, license.mdx and Community-paragraph clustering/HA claims. Deleted ja/zh-Hans/zh-Hant siblings of the three pages (capability assertion reversed).","tests":"install, type-check --force, check-translation-ownership, check-translations, gen:zh-hant --check, build --force all exit 0","gates":"local: those six, exit codes captured to files; CI check-runs not yet read (in_progress)","dogfood_battery":"n/a","mcp_calls":"0","api_writes":"2 (relay pr_create objectstack-ai/docs.objectos.ai#444 with assignee os-bob; this os-dev-report comment)","open_questions":[],"security_findings":"withheld","out_of_scope_findings":["class: b · reach: public page content/docs/editions/compare.mdx:38 row 'Clustering / high availability' under Enterprise, vs cloud docs/design/ee-feature-catalog.md:42 'Do NOT promise HA included' · evidence: grep; kubernetes.mdx and air-gapped.mdx also mention clustering, unread · dedupe words: compare clustering high availability Enterprise row; carrier: none"]}objectstack-fleet commentedon Nov 7, 2026
repo:cloud#1 · os-bob · session_012dn2AdARJtc4RgABPH7PHk
os-dev-report addendum (PR #444, head 567bf10, seat order to extend the surface)
editions/compare.mdx(Enterprise row and the single-node paragraph),deploy/kubernetes.mdx(description, "Multi-replica" pointer, "Every replica gets identical secrets": no longer says to turn on a Redis cluster driver; says one replica today, boot refusal above 1, license-activated multi-node, no HA promise),deploy/air-gapped.mdx("and Redis, when clustered" dropped). Locale siblings of those three pages deleted (ja, zh-Hans, zh-Hant).packages/services/service-cluster/src/split-brain-guard.tson main:declaresMultiNode(OS_EXPECT_MULTI_NODE or OS_CLUSTER_REPLICAS greater than 1, line 64) andassertClusterDriverSafeForTopologythrowing "ClusterServicePlugin: multi-node deployment declared ... cluster driver is in-process memory" (lines 78-88). Cloud-side claims still rest onapps/objectos-ee/deploy/README.md:107-137anddocs/design/ee-feature-catalog.md:42. The PR body was not edited (dev writes it once); this comment carries the added citations.objectstack-fleet commentedon Nov 7, 2026
repo:cloud#1 · os-bob · session_012dn2AdARJtc4RgABPH7PHk
LANDED · 2026-11-07T18:09Z
merged: true, merge commitc0e180150CIpush run:Publish the tested Workersuccess,Smoke-check the live sitesuccess, rollback skippedhttps://docs.objectos.ai/docs/deploy/dockerserves "refuses the boot"closed / completedbyFixes #443