Skip to content
Merged
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
68 changes: 49 additions & 19 deletions docs/status/PROOF-STATUS.adoc
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -88,9 +88,12 @@ missing crate as missing from every build.
(`8edb9da`), same invocation, at commit `336768958d01`, run 42896264290.
The file SHA-256 is unchanged, and the log reports no postulate in the cone
(`Agda.Primitive`, `FeatureReachability`).
* CI receipt (current, 2026-11-13): the same, at main `034f215`, run
* CI receipt (superseded on 2026-11-17): the same, at main `034f215`, run
43498592499. It records the inputs manifest and the axioms (none) that
PROOF-POLICY §8.5.1 now requires (standards `e5a39d7`).
* CI receipt (current, 2026-11-17): the same, at main `8c55804`, run 44190913019,
under the gate of #107. The file SHA-256 is unchanged, and the log reports
no postulate in the cone.

|Rocq leg
|`PROVEN`, route `re-proved`, correspondence `RECONCILED`. Receipt:
Expand All @@ -107,10 +110,17 @@ missing crate as missing from every build.
* Negative controls: a planted false lemma is rejected. A planted
`Admitted` compiles, and `Print Assumptions` reports it as an axiom.
* Receipt state: superseded on 2026-11-10 by the CI receipt below.
* CI receipt (current): Rocq 8.18.0 in the pinned Guix (`8edb9da`), same
invocation, at commit `336768958d01`, run 42896264290. The file SHA-256 is
unchanged, and `Print Assumptions` reports `absent_under_all_features`
closed under the global context.
* CI receipt (superseded on 2026-11-13): Rocq 8.18.0 in the pinned Guix
(`8edb9da`), same invocation, at commit `336768958d01`, run 42896264290.
The file SHA-256 is unchanged, and `Print Assumptions` reports
`absent_under_all_features` closed under the global context.
* CI receipt (superseded on 2026-11-17): the same, at main `034f215`, run
43498592499, with the inputs manifest and the axioms (none).
* CI receipt (current, 2026-11-17): the same, at main `8c55804`, run 44190913019,
under the gate of #107. The file SHA-256 is unchanged. `Print Assumptions`
reports all 11 declarations of the file closed under the global context,
and the kernel checker `coqchk -o` reports no axiom, type-in-type, unsafe
(co)fixpoint or assumed positivity in the library or its import cone.

|Lean leg
|`PROVEN`, route `re-proved`, correspondence `RECONCILED`. Receipt:
Expand All @@ -132,9 +142,16 @@ missing crate as missing from every build.
definition are rejected. A planted `sorry` compiles with a warning, and
`#print axioms` reports `sorryAx`.
* Receipt state: superseded on 2026-11-10 by the CI receipt below.
* CI receipt (current): Lean 4.29.0 in the pinned Guix (`8edb9da`), same
invocation, at commit `336768958d01`, run 42896264290. The file SHA-256 is
unchanged, and no declared theorem depends on an axiom.
* CI receipt (superseded on 2026-11-13): Lean 4.29.0 in the pinned Guix
(`8edb9da`), same invocation, at commit `336768958d01`, run 42896264290.
The file SHA-256 is unchanged, and no declared theorem depends on an axiom.
* CI receipt (superseded on 2026-11-17): the same, at main `034f215`, run
43498592499, with the inputs manifest and an empty axiom list. That list
is the vacuous one described below.
* CI receipt (current, 2026-11-17): the same, at main `8c55804`, run 44190913019,
under the gate of #107, with the propositional theorems. The log reports
"axioms: none for 8 theorem(s) and 48 definition(s) with a source range",
and the file declares no axiom.
* Axiom evidence, corrected 2026-11-17. Every THY-1 result in this file is a
`def` (the leg is Type-valued, like the Agda), and until 2026-11-17 the
gate audited theorems only. So the empty `(axioms)` element of the Lean
Expand All @@ -153,9 +170,9 @@ missing crate as missing from every build.
is "axioms: none for 8 theorem(s) and 48 definition(s) with a source
range". `absent_under_all_features` and the other five carry each
definition in their own `#print axioms` cone as well. No axiom was found, so none had
to be removed. A CI receipt under the fixed gate is still to be earned:
until it is, the current receipt's axiom evidence for this leg stays the
vacuous one.
to be removed. The CI receipt under the fixed gate was earned on
2026-11-17 (run 44190913019, main `8c55804`, above), so the current receipt's
axiom evidence for this leg is no longer the vacuous one.

|Why neither leg is transported
|Lambdapi's Rocq and Lean exports translate before elaboration and drop
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -228,7 +245,7 @@ same reader derives
|`pwg`
|`1` (since 2026-11-10): `PWG-2ii`, and every counted witness has a current
receipt from one headless, isolated, pinned CI run on the exact source commit
(PROOF-POLICY §8.2): `336768958d01` until 2026-11-13, `034f215` since. The grade holds while those receipts stay
(PROOF-POLICY §8.2): `336768958d01` until 2026-11-13, `034f215` until 2026-11-17, `8c55804` since. The grade holds while those receipts stay
current: a later commit that breaks a leg, or a run that cannot be repeated,
drops it (§8.4). Before 2026-11-10 it was `2ii`, because each receipt came
from a local run.
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -269,8 +286,9 @@ stated by no declaration (proof audit 2026-11-16, finding 33).
|`PROVEN`, route `re-proved`. `verification/proofs/coq/Cohort.v`, Rocq
8.18.0. The gate's `Print Assumptions` finds all 89 theorems closed under
the global context, and since 2026-11-17 every definition and fixpoint as
well: 134 declarations in all (82 theorems at the current receipt; the
seven added for APP-1's middle clause have no receipt yet). The kernel
well: 134 declarations in all. The current receipt (run 44190913019) covers all
of them; the receipt before it (run 43498592499) covered 82 theorems, before
the seven of APP-1's middle clause. The kernel
checker `coqchk -o` finds no axiom, type-in-type, unsafe (co)fixpoint or
assumed positivity in the compiled library or its import cone, the
standard library included (gate, 2026-11-17). The standard library's
Expand All @@ -280,9 +298,10 @@ file.
|Lean leg
|`PROVEN`, route `re-proved`. `verification/proofs/lean4/Cohort.lean`,
Lean 4.29.0, core only. The gate's audit finds no axiom in any of the 102
theorems or in the 128 definitions with a source range (95 theorems at the
current receipt; the seven added for APP-1's middle clause have no receipt
yet), and the file declares no axiom of its own. No `simp`, `omega` or `ac_rfl`: each brings `propext` in.
theorems or in the 128 definitions with a source range, and the file
declares no axiom of its own. The current receipt (run 44190913019) covers all of
them; the receipt before it covered 95 theorems, before the seven of APP-1's
middle clause. No `simp`, `omega` or `ac_rfl`: each brings `propext` in.

|Statement correspondence (§2.2)
|Compared by reading, item by item. Each target restates every Agda
Expand All @@ -309,8 +328,9 @@ Residual assumptions: none in any leg.

|Machine receipt (§8.5.1)
|`verification/receipts/theory_praxis.deed`, with THY-1. The current receipts
come from CI run 43498592499 on main `034f215` (Agda 2.7.0.1, Rocq 8.18.0,
Lean 4.29.0, pinned Guix `8edb9da`). Each records the inputs manifest of its
come from CI run 44190913019 on main `8c55804` (Agda 2.7.0.1, Rocq 8.18.0,
Lean 4.29.0, pinned Guix `8edb9da`), the first under the gate of #107; the
receipts of run 43498592499 on main `034f215` are superseded. Each records the inputs manifest of its
prover and no axiom. The canon reader at standards `e5a39d7` derives `PWG-1`
for each of APP-1 to APP-4, and the shared git checker (`just receipt-check`)
passes. The Rocq and Lean legs are `RECONCILED` by the comparison above, done
Expand All @@ -336,6 +356,16 @@ bash tests/proofs/gate_controls_test.sh agda
|===
|Date |Change

|2026-11-17
|The receipt is earned again from CI run 44190913019 on main `8c55804`, the
first under the gate of #107: for THY-1 and APP-1 to APP-4, in Agda, Rocq
and Lean. The receipts of run 43498592499 on `034f215` are superseded,
each with its reason. THY-1's Lean leg now has axiom evidence from an audit
that inspected its results. The two run-42896264290 receipts that this page
still called current are marked superseded, as they have been since
2026-11-13. The reader derives `PWG-1` for all five, and the shared git
checker passes. The claim pins move to this receipt in the next change.

|2026-11-17
|APP-1's middle clause is proved in Agda, Rocq and Lean (`verdict-missing`,
`verdict-not-false`, `verdict-not-yes`; owner ruling: prove, not narrow).
Expand Down
9 changes: 9 additions & 0 deletions docs/status/ROADMAP.adoc
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -306,6 +306,15 @@ One pull request that changes census rows is open at a time (atlas README,
theorems. The Hypatia scanner pin moves to `b7944d3` (hypatia#1087, the
JavaScript-aware `js_exec_sync` rule), and `scripts/site/site.mjs` drops
its `hypatia:ignore` annotation.
** Third change (2026-11-17), after PR 107: APP-1's middle clause is proved
in all three provers, and the gate audits definitions as well as
theorems, refuses an empty audit and a declared Lean axiom, and checks
each Rocq library and its import cone with the kernel checker
`coqchk -o`. The receipt is written again from CI run 44190913019 on main
`8c55804`, the first under that gate; THY-1's Lean leg gains axiom
evidence that inspected its results. Next: the claim pins of THY-1 and
APP-1 to APP-4 move to this receipt, and APP-1's pin names
`verdict-missing` and `verdict-not-yes`.

[[stages]]
== Stages
Expand Down
Loading
Loading