You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
emrg: the promote template has no rule for a post that drew no interaction #2908
emrg/server/promote_prompt.md §2.y (Blog Publishing) tells a round how to pick a topic, in what
order to work, how often to publish, and how to record what it published. §6 measures the result: it
asks for "views, reactions, comments, follows on published posts" and for the round's star/fork
delta.
Nothing in the file says what a round does with a post those figures show nobody engaged with. The
round measures the post, records the number, and the post stands.
The nearest rules are about other things. §2's "Long-term silence → remove from the tracking list,
record 'dormant'" is about a thread this account replied in, not a piece it published. The red
lines' "flagged / negative response" rule is about a hostile reaction, which is a different signal
from silence.
Why it matters
The measurement exists to change the next round's behaviour, and a failed post is the sharpest
evidence a promotion task gets: it is the one case where the round's own output is judged by readers
rather than by the round. Without a rule the archive accumulates posts nobody read, each still
carrying the account's name on the channel, and the round holds no recorded lesson to act on — so
the next piece is written the same way and the same failure repeats.
A second effect matters as much: a round with nothing to do about a dead post has no reason to read
that post's figures beyond the summary line, so the measurement becomes a number in a table rather
than a decision.
What the fix must satisfy
A published piece that drew no interaction past a fixed window is removed from the platform,
and the removal is recorded as a failure case: the title, the date, the form, what the piece tried
to do, and the specific change the next one makes.
The criterion is interaction, not reach — reactions and comments from readers, never views,
because reach is the platform's distribution while engagement is the only evidence a reader took
the piece.
The window is stated, and a piece still inside it, or one that drew any engagement at all, is left
untouched.
The rule lives in the section that owns blog publishing, and a guard reads the rendered prompt
to prove it is there — and that no other section has taken the subject over.
Activity
how2how2how2-arch commentedon Nov 15, 2026
Handled by #2909