Please yank 7.2.19 release

[dolfinus]

New release 7.2.19 introduced breaking changes - all arguments of methods suddenly became keyword-only in PR #1505. This affected a lot of projects - see #1532, #1533, #1534

This level of change should never be a part of the patch release. Please yank this release, and introduce proper major release 8.0.0 #1530.

[rraulinio]

#1535 is opened to fix that for the patch release, we are handling it, no worries.

[dolfinus]

But could you yank breaking release in PyPI until this fix is applied?

[harshavardhana]

But could you yank breaking release in PyPI until this fix is applied?

No we will make another v7.2.20 soon - it doesn't need to be yanked.

[dolfinus]

All projects which use this package without upper version limit are now broken, and have to release their own patch versions to prevent installing 7.2.19

[ThimoNeubauer]

I just introduced a minio!=7.2.19 in our internal pipeline. As long as this version isn't yanked I guess that many other users will need to do the same...

Long story short: +1 for yanking

[ThimoNeubauer]

At this moment the broken version is still the latest release on https://pypi.org/project/minio/#history

[quanghuy1288]

I match this issue today, lost so many time to fix it

[mfussenegger]

But could you yank breaking release in PyPI until this fix is applied?

If people already updated and added a >= 7.2.19 constraint (like we did), yanking it would cause another break.
Releasing a 7.2.20 without the strict kwargs change seems like the better option. It fixes it for people without constraint, without breaking it for people who moved ahead.

[dolfinus]

If people already updated and added a >= 7.2.19 constraint (like we did), yanking it would cause another break.

It will not, as old arguments style def method(self, arg1, arg2) allows using keyword arguments self.method(arg1=..., arg2=...).

[mfussenegger]

If people already updated and added a >= 7.2.19 constraint (like we did), yanking it would cause another break.

It will not, as old arguments style def method(self, arg1, arg2) allows using keyword arguments self.method(arg1=..., arg2=...).

But pip install minio>=7.2.19 will fail