Summary
Agent Runtime deployment operation state in v1.3.1 is a non-atomic read/modify/write record without an owner token. Two CLI processes can both pass the pending-operation check, start remote mutations, and overwrite or clear each other's deployment_metadata.json state.
Baseline: 5a306f8956cb1eeae69f9709de0e4d61b44e11e7 (v1.3.1).
Reproduction
- In one agent project, start two
agents-cli deploy --no-wait processes at the same time.
- Both read the metadata before either writes its pending operation.
- Observe that both may submit a remote create/update, while the last metadata write wins.
- Also simulate:
- local SDK request-config construction failing before remote submission;
- remote create/update submission raising with an unknown outcome;
- a delayed status/cleanup process running after a newer operation replaced the record.
Actual behavior
- More than one remote mutation can start.
- One process can overwrite or clear another process's pending operation.
- A crash between remote submission and operation-name persistence is not represented safely.
- Failure cleanup cannot distinguish known pre-mutation failure from outcome-uncertain remote submission.
Expected behavior
- Exactly one process owns the right to start a mutation.
- Ownership spans target revalidation, remote submission, status recording, completion, and cleanup.
- Local preparation failure restores prior metadata byte-for-byte.
- Once remote submission or identity creation may have happened, retain a fail-closed
starting claim for manual reconciliation.
- A stale owner must never clear a replacement owner's record.
- Successful completion should merge current sibling metadata and remove the owned claim in one atomic transition.
Minimal fix
Use a cross-process lock around metadata read/modify/write, add a random claim ID, claim before remote mutation, revalidate the selected Runtime while holding ownership, and make clear/finish operations owner-aware. Split local request preparation from remote submission so only errors proven to precede mutation restore the previous bytes.
Reference implementation and regressions: fork Batch 4 branch.
Verification evidence
- Thread and subprocess races each produced exactly one owner and exactly one mutation.
- Replacement-owner, legacy-operation, atomic-finish, and sibling-metadata regressions passed.
- Local request-config failure: zero mutation, byte-identical restoration, retry claim succeeds.
- Remote submit and identity-create outcome-uncertain failures retain
state=starting.
- Fresh targeted review: 35 tests passed; full local suite: 92 passed.
ruff check src tests, ty check src, build, and Python 3.11/3.13 installed-wheel smoke tests passed.
Summary
Agent Runtime deployment operation state in v1.3.1 is a non-atomic read/modify/write record without an owner token. Two CLI processes can both pass the pending-operation check, start remote mutations, and overwrite or clear each other's
deployment_metadata.jsonstate.Baseline:
5a306f8956cb1eeae69f9709de0e4d61b44e11e7(v1.3.1).Reproduction
agents-cli deploy --no-waitprocesses at the same time.Actual behavior
Expected behavior
startingclaim for manual reconciliation.Minimal fix
Use a cross-process lock around metadata read/modify/write, add a random claim ID, claim before remote mutation, revalidate the selected Runtime while holding ownership, and make clear/finish operations owner-aware. Split local request preparation from remote submission so only errors proven to precede mutation restore the previous bytes.
Reference implementation and regressions: fork Batch 4 branch.
Verification evidence
state=starting.ruff check src tests,ty check src, build, and Python 3.11/3.13 installed-wheel smoke tests passed.